Why the ICJ ruling won’t stop the Rohingya genocide
20 November 2026
This story was originally published by The New Humanitarian.
In a historic judgement, the UN’s top court has found that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya minority. This is the first time since its founding that an international court has found a state – rather than individuals – to have violated the 1948 Genocide Convention.
The International Court of Justice’s judgement was a rare moment of celebration and justice for many Rohingya, the ethnic minority group who endured decades of discrimination by Myanmar before 2016 and 2017, when security forces and local militias began a campaign of mass murder, sexual violence, and destruction that forced more than 700,000 to flee across the border to Bangladesh in so-called “clearance operations”. At least 10,000 people are estimated to have been killed.
The case – especially how the court determined genocidal intent – is likely to have implications for future claims of genocide at the ICJ including South Africa’s current case that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza. But given that the ICJ does not have the power to enforce its judgements, there is little reason to believe that the Rohingya will see any practical change or action any time soon.
Shortly after the judgement, The New Humanitarian spoke with Penny Green, professor of law and globalisation at Queen Mary University of London, to get her initial take on the judgement and what it means. Green is an expert on state violence, has conducted extensive research in Myanmar, and is the founder and director of the International State Crime Initiative (ISCI).
Her new book, written with co-author Thomas MacManus, is called “Chronicle of a Genocide Foretold: Myanmar and the Rohingya”.
“The international legal framework is not designed to deliver justice. It can’t. That’s because genocide isn’t a legal problem, it’s a political problem,” Green said. “Unless you deal with the structural nature of the genocide where it is occurring, and deal with the states that enable genocide, nothing will change for the Rohingya.”
Here’s what she had to say on international justice, alternative approaches, and the idea of genocide as a process.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
The New Humanitarian: What are your main takeaways following the judgement?
Penny Green: This is a judgment which comes well over a decade too late. And all of the evidence pointing to this genocide was available from 2012 onwards, at least. It’s a genocide that began in the 1970s, but really picked up pace after 2012, when there were pogroms in Sittwe, the capital of Rakhine State.
I’m not one of those people who waits with bated breath for a determination from international courts. My colleagues and I at the International State Crime Initiative began researching the Rohingya in 2012, and we notified the British government at the time that we foresaw a genocide of the Rohingya taking place. We did a huge research project in Myanmar in 2015 and provided the evidence base that said a genocide was already happening, and the government responded it’s not a genocide until a court of law determines it is.
So governments like the UK have known about this developing genocide for well over a decade. For this and all sorts of reasons, I take a very cautious approach to international courts, including the International Criminal Court (ICC) and the ICJ, especially because they don’t have enforcement mechanisms.
The New Humanitarian: The judgement does say that Myanmar should pay compensation or other reparations to the Rohingya, although it leaves the question of how that might work for future court proceedings. How would this work given that the ICJ does not have any power to enforce its rulings?
Green: The Myanmar regime, which is a military regime, has always denied and will continue to deny accusations of genocide, so it will not be affording the Rohingya any form of reparations of all.
The rulings on reparations are purely symbolic goals. They are not even punishments, because Myanmar is supported by very powerful regional powers: China, India, and Russia. China and Russia sit on the UN Security Council, so they will veto any resolution to punish Myanmar, should there be one. But I don’t think we should expect anything from the Security Council.
The New Humanitarian: Do you see anything in this ruling beside symbolism?
Green: I’m getting a lot of texts from Rohingya friends in the camps in Bangladesh, and they are celebrating. In a lot of ways, it is an affirmation that what they have experienced has been recognised. That has value in itself.
But part of the problem has been that so many victims of genocide put a great deal of faith in the international courts who either do not deliver, or not for over a decade, and who cannot deliver meaningful justice.
The international legal framework is not designed to deliver justice. It can’t. That’s because genocide isn’t a legal problem, it’s a political problem. Unless you deal with the structural nature of the genocide where it is occurring, and deal with the states that enable genocide, nothing will change for the Rohingya.
The New Humanitarian: There has been so much debate over the past few years, since Israel began its bombardment of Gaza after the Hamas attacks on 7 October 2023, about when it is appropriate to use the word “genocide”. You have been using genocide to describe what has happened to the Rohingya, and to the Palestinians in Gaza, for years. What’s your take on the word and its usage?
Green: I think one has to understand genocide is a process, not an event. It’s not just some kind of spectacularised event of mass violence. It begins with strategies of dehumanisation, which create major opportunities for sporadic violence. That violence leads to segregation and isolation. For the Rohingya, segregation took the form of squalid camps, ghettos, and prison villages inside Rakhine State following the 2012 state-sponsored pogroms led by Rakhine nationalists against the Rohingya communities of Sittwe.
Once people are segregated – where people are too frightened to leave because of fear of violence – it’s much easier to systematically weaken the targeted population. In camps, people rely on aid, and we know the World Food Programme at various points cut the calorie content of its aid packages when it faced funding pressure.
The weakened community are then much easier to annihilate in various forms. So you can engage in mass slaughter as the regime did in northern Rakhine State in 2016-2017, and you can forcibly expel people, which is also what happened in that period with 750-800,000 Rohingya forced to cross the border during what the regime called “military clearance operations”.
The New Humanitarian: While the ICC has a formal process for victims to participate in its proceedings, the ICJ does not. Do you think this is an important part of the process?
Green: That’s the problem with the international courts. It disempowers civil society. It disempowers victims’ groups. It disempowers those who have been struggling to expose the genocide, and it puts all the power in the hands of judges, barristers, and court officials, and I think that that’s a very, very problematic element of the international courts.
The other thing is that the courts rely on the work of civil society groups by using the evidence they collect, but they don’t have an opportunity to testify and present their evidence. They don’t get a platform. Instead, their contributions must be filtered through the medium of the court and the lawyers.
The New Humanitarian: What do you see as an alternative to these systems for victims of genocide who are seeking some sort of justice?
Green: One alternative is a People’s Tribunal, [an independently-organised tribunal that stages hearings similar to those in courts to address impunity]. I’m on the steering committee of the Gaza Tribunal, which has been dealing with Israel’s genocide against the Palestinians, and the International State Crime Initiative held a people’s tribunal in London for the Rohingya in 2017. You gather evidence, gather expert and witness testimony. You hear directly from victims and their allies. International courts don’t deal as much with history and context, but that’s what a people’s tribunal can do.
The New Humanitarian: What can a people’s tribunal practically do?
Green: People’s Tribunals are powerful because they draw on the strength of organised civil society, encourage international solidarity and civil resistance, and promote initiatives such as boycotts, divestment, and sanctions (BDS) to punish offending states – a strategy that has been used most effectively in Palestine against Israel. The BDS movement has been comparatively effective. It hasn’t stopped the genocide, but it has caused pain to the Israeli state.
Courts are argued to be the most legitimate source of decision-making in terms of issues related to justice, but actually civil society has a great degree of legitimacy. And in the cases of both the Rohingya and the Palestinians, civil society organisations have been gathering evidence of state crimes for decades. The evidence of genocide in both Myanmar and Palestine is extensive and it has existed for many years, but courts only trust their own evidence-sourcing mechanisms. At the Gaza Tribunal, we heard testimonies from hundreds of people, witnesses from Gaza and the West Bank and from scholars, journalists, and activists from around the world. People’s Tribunals can receive testimony in a way that can’t be achieved in an international court.
The New Humanitarian: Even though you are sceptical, this case is the first time a state has been held responsible for genocide since the convention in 1948. Do you think that anything will change, at least in terms of public perception of the Rohingya and the genocide?
Green: I think attention will focus on the Rohingya but for the briefest moment; but the ICJ verdict of genocide is very unlikely to evince real change. Real change can only really come from within Myanmar and the overthrow of the military dictatorship. It is a political question. Myanmar’s genocide is effectively enabled by states like China and India – who have strong economic ties with Myanmar. While they continue with those economic ties, then nothing changes. Things will not change if states see a benefit in continuing to work with genocidal states.
I also don’t think it will change the condition for the Rohingya in the short or medium term. This judgement is powerful symbolically, and I wouldn’t want to take away from that. But it’s very unlikely to make a real difference to the conditions of the 1.2 million Rohingya refugees living in the camps in Bangladesh, to the Rohingya guest workers working in the Middle East in appalling conditions, or to the Rohingya who are languishing in the most squalid camps inside Rakhine State, or those living in fear in northern Rakhine State.
Myanmar and Bangladesh are in repatriation negotiations, but the point is that the Rohingya cannot return until they are afforded citizenship, until they are afforded a safe and secure environment in which to live, until they are afforded the most basic human rights. Anything else exposes them to further mass violence and the continuing genocide, because the genocide has not stopped.
The New Humanitarian: What do you mean by the statement that the genocide has not stopped?
Green: The court focused on a very specific timeframe of mass violence and set of circumstances, and that’s part of the problem. The genocide wasn’t just that moment of extreme violence… genocide is a process, often developing over decades. It can have moments of the kind of mass violence that we saw in 2016 and 2017, but the slow erasure of the Rohingya identity began many years earlier and continues today. You can’t use the word Rohingya inside Myanmar; rather they continue to be labelled illegal Bengali immigrants.
In Bangladesh, the Rohingya remain stateless, they are denied a full education, they rely on food aid, and they do not enjoy freedom of movement or adequate health care. This is not to suggest they are a hapless people: They have built communities inside the Bangladesh camps despite being deeply traumatised because of what they have experienced. But the point of genocide is to erase in whole or part the identity of a people or the people themselves, and that for the Rohingya is a continuing state of trauma.
Edited by Andrew Gully.
–––––
The New Humanitarian puts quality, independent journalism at the service of the millions of people affected by humanitarian crises around the world. Find out more at www.thenewhumanitarian.org.