phim sex vlxx sex viet sex vietsub phim sex vietsub phimsexsub phim sex nhật bản phim xxx phimsex sex hay phim sex hay sexvietsub jav vietsub sex sub phim xex phim sex sub phim sex mới haysex phim se phim sex mới nhất javsub heo69 sex viet sub sexsub phim sex viet sub sex vietsud phim sex vlxx sex nhật không che vlxyz sex3x phim người lớn jav sub phim sex vietsud phim sex việt sub phim x phim sex phụ đề phim sex vietsub không che xxx việt phim s sex vietsup sex vietsub không che sex phim phim sex vietsup vlxx.com phim sex moi phímex fim sex sex viétub viet sex sex việt sub phim sex. phim sex nhật không che phím sex vlxx. javphim phim sex viétub xxx vietsub phim se x phim sex phu de vlxc phim sex viêt sex không che vietsub xxx nhật phim sex moi nhat vlxx.sex xxx viet phimsex vietsub vkxx phim sex loạn luân nhật bản phim sex không che vietsub javvietsub sex châu âu vietsub phim sexsub phimsexsud phimsexvietsub phim sex xxx phin sex vlzx phim sex vl sex vietsub ko che jav việt sex vietsub khong che xem phim sex vietsub sex nhật vietsub phim sex vietsub khong che lvxx sex trung sub jav phim phim set my phim+sex phim sex viet sup sẽ việt phim sex việt mới nhất phum sex jav nhật sex viet sup phim set nhat ban phim sexvietsub vlxz jav mới phim sex việt nam phim sex viet nam phim sex trung quốc phim sex vn phim sex không che phim sex việt phim sex mỹ phim sex hàn quốc phim sex anime phim sex viet phim sex loạn luân phim sex nhật phim sex ko che phim sex loan luan phim sex thái lan xem phim sex phim sex gái xinh phim sex hiếp dâm phim sex châu âu phim sex khong che phim sex việt nam mới nhất phim sex hồng kông phim sex gay phim sex trần hà linh phim sex online phim sex vietnam phim sex trung quoc phim sex cổ trang xem phim sex việt nam phim sex hoạt hình phim sex trung phim sex học sinh phim sex bố chồng nàng dâu phim sex my phim sex jav phim sex china phim sex thủ dâm phim sex nhật bản không che coi phim sex phim sex phá trinh phim sex hd phim sex tập thể phim sex đài loan phim sex hàn phim sex thái phim sex ấn độ phim sex nhat ban phim sex hentai phim sex vú to phim sex nhat phim sex top 1 phim sex k che phim sex việt nam không che phim sex massage phim sex phương mỹ chi phim sex vụng trộm phim sex quay lén phim sex âu mỹ phim sex hay nhất phim sex cô giáo thảo phim sex viêt nam phim sex bà già phim sex mẹ con phim sex live phim sex địt nhau coi phim sex việt nam phim sex máy bay bà già phim sex cấp 3 phim sex han quoc phim sex nga phim sex việt nam mới phim sex bú lồn phim sex phim sex phim sex linh miu phim sex hiep dam phim sex top1 phim sex mbbg phim sex 2024 phim sex viet nam moi nhat phim sex việt nam có tiếng phim sex trung quốc vietsub phim sex gai xinh sex việt sex việt nam sex vn sex viet nam phim heo địt nhau sex không che sexviet sex ko che clip sex phim 18+ sexx phim sẽ sex vietnam phim set phim 18 phim xet sex jav dit nhau phim xx phim địt nhau sex mới phim sec phim xes sex k che sex khong che sex nhat sayuri hayama phim con heo phim sexx xxx vn phim xec đit nhau sexhay jav không che xxx việt nam sex viêt sex việt mới xem sex sex moi phim dit nhau clip sex việt sexxx phim xét sex việt mới nhất phim18 phimloz phim set viet nam vlxxx clip sex viet phimset sex trung quốc vietsub xxx ko che clip sex vn jav ko che phim sét clip sex viet nam sex việt nam! xxx không che sex nhật bản không che xemphimsextv phimxx sex viêt nam sex anime ko che phim vlxx sex mới nhất phim sex.com sex vlxx dmsex sex video sex địt nhau video sex phim xxxx xem địt nhau sex anime không che sex trung vietsub sex viet moi đụ nhau sex kh che sex 18+ xem phim địt nhau sex hihi sexmup sex phụ đề jav khong che tải phim sex sex nhật ko che xxx trung sex việt hay phim 18 + phimsexvietnam sex việt nam mới địt nhau không che phim heo vn xem sex việt nam phim set vn se x phim xex việt nam sex online clip sex mới nhất phim ses jav.hd sex vn mới nhất hayama sayuri phimsec sex việt nam không che không che phim set việt nam phim sex có phụ đề sex sex phim sẽ vn phim sech phim sex 18+ sexmoi phim sexxx chịch việt nam xxx viet nam sex viet hay sex viẹt sex đẹp sex gái sexx vn sex link clip sex mới phim sex nước ngoài sex viet moi nhat phim xxx việt nam chiếu phim sex phim sez phimsexviet phim xes việt nam sex vl phim nguoi lon sexgai sex v phimsexhay phim sex hàn quốc không che sexhayvc link sex mới phim xéc sex 18 xem phim sex không che phim sex loạn luân không che phim sex anime không che phim sẽ việt nam phim xét việt nam phim xxx vn phim 18+ vietsub phimsexhd123 xvideos3 xem phim sex hàn quốc sexsot vlxx việt nam sex viet mới phim sex việt mới phim sex vn mới nhất dịt nhau xnxx xxx xvideo pornhub xvideos porn hub xhamster xxnx xnx xxx video xhamter sex xxx xvideo.com xnxx.com xvideos.com xvdeo x video pornhud pornhup xnxxxx pronhub xvdeos xham video xxx poỏn videoxxx sex porn xnxx com porhub xnxn porn hud deepfake porn xxx my xxx.com xnxc pornhun nxxx sex.com xvide sex videos sextube xnxx. sex movie xxx sex viet69 cliphotvn link sex viet 69 sexvn sex việt nam mới nhất lộ clip sex việt 69 clipsex sex nhanh viet69.net clip sex hot sex viet 88 viet69. sex lộ link địt nhau việt nam phim heo việt nam cliphot vn clipphot sex viet88 sex lộ clip sex trung quốc sex anime sex trung sex nhật sex châu âu sex trần hà linh sex gái xinh sex gay sex mỹ live sex sex china sex nhật bản anime sex sex thủ dâm sex top 1 sex hàn quốc sex cosplay sex loạn luân trần hà linh sex sex hàn sex live sex học sinh sex trung quoc sex top1 sex hiếp dâm sex my truyện tranh sex ảnh sex sex education sex quay lén sex vú to sex hd sex âu mỹ sex 3d sex hà linh sex cổ trang sex nhat ban sex tq sex hentai clip sex việt nam sex thái lan sex loan luan sex tập thể truyện sex sex tran ha linh sex linh miu sex phá trinh sex mbbg gay sex clip sex trần hà linh sex hoạt hình sex chau au sex tối cổ sex gai xinh cosplay sex sex top sex phương mỹ chi sex les sex toy sex sinh viên chat sex sex doggy roblox sex game sex sex gay anime anh sex sex nga sex massage sex 2k9 sex thái sex âu sex vụng trộm sex bú cu sex chibi sex tây sex roblox clip sex phương mỹ chi clip sex hiền hồ sex one piece sex hiền hồ sex gái xinh trung quốc sex 2k8 sex mẹ con sex china news sex teen sex loli sex thu dam massage sex sex gái xinh việt nam sex anna gấu xxvideo xvideo98 xvideo69 xxxvideo xvideos98 sex 69 xvideos99 xxvideos videox phim sex miễn phí sex moi nhat xvideo99 phim sex v xes việt nam xvideo vn phim sex xx video sex việt nam phim sex nhật bản mới nhất xxxvideos sex nhau sex bắn tùm lum sex vn 2023 svideox xvideovietnam xvideo việt nam sex98 xvideos69 xvideos 98 xvideox xxx videos free porn xem sex viet nam phim sex cực hay jav javhd missav thisav javhay jav hd njav javhiv phim jav javhdhay this av jav hay jav sex sexnhat hentai sextop1 hentaiz stripchat tuoi69 sextop chịch spankbang gái xinh thủ dâm fake taxi thiendia hentai 3d anime hentai rule 34 xxxx checkerviet sexdiary chibi1311 sieukhung taxi fake sweetie fox hentai ko che strip chat gái thủ dâm yua mikami bú lồn hentai.z móc lồn supjav truyện tranh hentai anime chịch hentai anime hentai one piece phimxxx melody mark rule34 phim hentai thanhlau anime 18+ lau xanh hentai z hen tai xxx anime lồn đẹp chịch anime melody marks sục cu hentai genshin sục cặc xxxxx anime xxx xnxxx thumbzilla one piece hentai mina kitano anny walker tran ha linh xemphimgay emi fukada hentai gay bdsm gái việt thủ dâm roblox r34 elle lee eva elfie china av xxx trung quốc gay porn phim cấp 3 game hentai lồn múp chịch gái xinh vnxx hentaizz hanime phimheo học sinh thủ dâm chaturbate henta hentai naruto anime địt nhau mia khalifa clipsexviet liếm lồn anime r34 youtubecliphot xlxx phá trinh chich nhau phim18hd blackpink r34 bóp vú ihentai hentai vn shen nana eimi fukada misav sxnm minami aizawa boyfriendtv javgg chinababe hentai manhwa rei kamiki full clip hot 3xchina momo sakura hongkongdoll miuzxc onlyfan leak sex diary lauxanh lilyxoxoles ai sayama manhwa hentai javful sex onlyfan nagi hikaru hentai manga genshin impact hentai rosie rider sex 2024 hentai game brazzers travelvids ixxx sexgay genshin hentai tiktok sex hentai nami sexvietnam sex gái xinh vn karen yuzuriha ssis-469 hentaix ssis 469 hentai ntr xmxx trần hà linh lộ clip gái xinh sex sexchauau jav việt nam trần hà linh xxx sex hack cam sextrungquoc tran ha linh sex phim sex chau au show lồn sex vn mới sex 2k6 phim sex tran ha linh sex bạn thân phim sex việt nam 2024 sex việt 2024 địt em gái sex máy bay xxx trần hà linh sextrung sex mẹ pim sex livestream sex rausex sex ha linh sex livestream clip tran ha linh suchibi trang sex sex viet 2024 phim xet viet nam sex viet nam moi nhat clip sex tran ha linh sex bé tôm sex 69vn buomtv subjav xxphim ihentaiz phimkk tiengruoi hihisex miu shiramine tut4k loạn luân xnxx vn xex loan luan quay len xxphe phim sẽ gầy miu shiromine quattv phim18d saika kawakita clip sex mi trần gai gu sex siêu nhân fukada ditnhau chịch gái nxx sex bạo dâm xxn sex hs vn sex hoc sinh sex hs mi trần sex 69vn.com xxx học sinh remu suzumori saoke ririko kinoshita mary tachibana phim loan luan sex mẹ kế phim cap 3 kana momonogi xxnxx sex some loanluan lonkk lồn to vungtrom xxx gái xinh sex em gái hikaru nagi học sinh chịch nhau xxx mỹ mikami yua chịch học sinh sex hiep dam thudam sex mông to làm tình rikka ono sex móc lồn sex cô giáo karen kaede chịch em gái phim sex mỹ đen phim sex mẹ kế arina hashimoto mio ishikawa mikami heo 69 link sex vn phim sex sinh viên sexnhanh hikari aozora thienvadia gai thu dam sex thu sex tap the sex69 phim sex loạn luân việt nam phim sex loan luan me con meguri javhd. sex bố chồng nàng dâu mei itsukaichi phim sex campuchia uno kanaya emi fukuda ryo ayumi yuna ogura liên quân r34 yu shinoda hình sex maki hojo thiendia88 mayuki ito phim sex gái đẹp ảnh nude hay88 tsukasa aoi sex hot gái xinh bú cu sex rên phim loạn luân sex vung trom jav69 phim đit nhau sex melody mark sex nami phim18+ ria yamate sex hồng kông địt gái xinh konan koyoi jav vn thủ dâm sex my readingmanga phim sex hiếp dâm tập thể sex pi tiên sẽ gầy không che suzu honjo phim sex vung trom sex loạn luân việt nam em gái thủ dâm phim xnxx phim sex hoc sinh phim sex sinh viên việt nam sex mĩ phim sex bà bầu vung trom live thủ dâm phim sex siêu nhân aoi ichino truyện sex gay sex vợ chồng sex gái đẹp eimi fukada sex hentai hiếp dâm vlzz sex thủ dâm vn emifukada phim sex les sex eimi fukada phim sex bú cu sex vú bự quay lén gái tắm sex sinh viên việt nam mỷeadingmanga yui hatano phim sex u50 phim sex loan luân quay lén tắm javhf phim sex tự sướng phim sex kh che vung trom.com xnnx phim sex education season 4 release date truyen sex sexmy phim sex bạo dâm riho fujimori yumi kazama dam69 jav k che sex đài loan mei washio clip xxx sex au my linh miu sex xxxvn phim sex vú bự sex cưỡi ngựa phim sex cha chồng nàng dâu rina ishihara sex melody ai kano sex2023 sẽ gầy ko che địt nhau vn maron natsuki thegioisex phim hiếp dâm yua mikami sex sex múp tube8 link sex việt nam amiri saitou coi phim sex hàn quốc vlxx com vlxx nghĩa là gì vlxx trung quốc vlxx viet nam vlxx vietsub vlxx không che vlxx vn vlxx việt sex vip tai phim sex web sex heo.vl phimxet sex. sexhd link sex mới nhất phimxes sex heo xem phim heo phim xech vlxx.moe sex nhât vl.xx xxvl phímexx xvlxx blxx mở phim sex phim sẽc seex phim sêx xexx xem xex phim séc phim xếch phim sex.net phimsexx phimx phin set xemphimsex phim sex vip sêx xem phim xec phim.set pim set phim sec nhat ban phim tình dục sexxxxx vlxx.tv phim sex heo wed sex phim seex vxll xem phim sex online phim sx trang phim sex xem phim xet phimsex.com phim dex clip sexx phm sex cho coi phim sex phim sex cosplay phim sex 2023 phim sex hà linh phim sex đam mỹ phim sex đồng tính nữ phim sex chibi phim sex gái xinh việt nam phim sex gái xinh trung quốc phim sex tq phim sex hiền hồ phim sex châu phi phim sex trung quốc không che phim sex học sinh việt nam phim sex máy bay bà già việt nam phim sex việt nam hay nhất phim sex hong kong phim sex người mẫu phim sex top sex vn hs phim sex ngoại tình sex ngoại tình phimxxx.vin Phim sex hay Phim sex Vietsub Phim sex không che Sex hiếp dâm Sex học sinh Vụng trộm - Ngoại tình Phim cấp 3 Sex Mỹ - Châu Âu XVIDEOS XNXX JAV XXX kiếm tiền online TikTok Shop Seller Center TikTok Shop Bán hàng online Cách đăng ký TikTok Shop tiktok seller seller tiktok seller center tiktokseller tiktokshop tiktok seller center fb shop affiliate tiktok tiktok shop tiktok shop seller center tiktok shop seller đăng ký tiktok shop tiktok shop đăng nhập cách tạo tiktok shop cách mở tiktok shop đăng nhập tiktok shop lazada seller center lazada lazada seller lazada seller center seller lazada lazada vietnam mã giảm giá lazada seller center lazada lazada center lazada tuyển dụng voucher lazada lazada vn lazada kênh người bán tổng đài lazada logo lazada tải lazada lazada affiliate lazada logo lazada seller đăng nhập lazada mall lazada việt nam lazada mua sắm lazada bán hàng lazada logistics lazada bán mã giảm giá lazada hôm nay bán hàng trên lazada lazada của nước nào cách bán hàng trên lazada cách hủy đơn hàng trên lazada ma giam gia lazada hotline lazada lazada career lazada center seller mã lazada lazada express affiliate lazada hoàn tiền lazada lazada philippines lazada group mã freeship lazada lazada malaysia sinh nhật lazada lazada seller centre tuyển dụng lazada lazada khuyen mai lazada thailand hoàn tiền mua sắm lazada lazada 11.11 lex vn seller own fleet tra cứu vận đơn tắt quảng cáo trên điện thoại samsung tra mã vận đơn lex vn kiểm tra đơn hàng lazada tra mã vận đơn lazada ahamove tracking lazada.vn đăng nhập mã giảm giá lazada cho người mới nhập mã giảm giá lazada lịch sử giá shopee đăng ký bán hàng trên lazada điểm gửi hàng lazada điểm gửi hàng lazada gần đây công ty lazada hủy đơn hàng lazada phí sàn lazada lazada hoàn tiền vào đâu lazada tuyển dụng giao hàng trả hàng lazada rút gọn link check giá shopee tong dai lazada gậy ba khúc lazada singapore lazada tphcm vib lazada cách đặt hàng trên lazada cách trả hàng lazada liên hệ lazada cách trả hàng trên lazada tra cứu đơn hàng lazada cách mua hàng trên lazada sinh nhat lazada trụ sở lazada sale lazada lừa đảo lazada đăng ký gian hàng lazada hoàn tiền max lazada thời gian hoàn tiền lazada lazada run tra cứu vận đơn cainiao lazada trả hàng hoàn tiền lazada xóa tài khoản lazada shopee và lazada của nước nào tra cứu điểm gửi hàng lazada trả góp lazada đơn vị vận chuyển lazada tiếp thị liên kết lazada tạo gian hàng trên lazada ảo ma canada khung shopee cách sử dụng xu trên lazada lazada indonesia lazada apk lazada run 2024 kho lazada tuyển dụng shopee cắt giảm nhân sự lazada api voucher hoàn tiền lazada la gì giao hàng lazada cách dùng xu lazada chạy quảng cáo lazada cách săn sale trên lazada tuyển dụng giao hàng lazada tphcm hủy liên kết momo với lazada lazada affiliate là gì liên kết momo với lazada cách sử dụng voucher hoàn tiền lazada sinh nhật lazada ngày nào sinh nhật lazada ngày mấy lazada affiliate program kho lazada lex vn ở đâu lazada live banner lazada black friday lazada đăng ký affiliate lazada cách kiếm tiền trên lazada cách sử dụng voucher tích lũy lazada hỗ trợ lazada địa điểm nhận hàng lex vn xử lý đơn hàng lazada tiktok shop tiktok seller đăng ký tiktok shop cách tạo tiktok shop tiktok shop partner mã giảm giá tiktok cách bán hàng trên tiktok tiktok shop logo cách mở tiktok shop khi chưa đủ follow phí sàn tiktok bán hàng trên tiktok tiktok global shop tiktok shop affiliate tiktok.com vn tiếp thị liên kết tiktok liên kết tiktok shop tiktokshop cách đăng ký tiktok shop trên điện thoại tiktok desktop những từ bị cấm trên tiktok chạy quảng cáo tiktok shop cách xóa tài khoản tiktok seller đổi tên tiktok shop cách mua hàng trên tiktok tra mã vận đơn tiktok shop mã khuyến mãi tiktok shop tên cửa hàng tiktok shop hay phí vận chuyển tiktok shop ai trả cách thêm sản phẩm liên kết trên tiktok shop cách mở tiktok shop trên điện thoại cách mở tiktok shop điều kiện mở tiktok shop khóa học tiktok shop tổng đài tiktok đơn vị vận chuyển của tiktok shop cách rút tiền trên tiktok tiktok live cách xóa sản phẩm liên kết trên tiktok shop cách đăng bán hàng trên tiktok tiktokseller chính sách của tiktok shop đăng ký tài khoản nhận hoa hồng tiktok shop affiliate cách xoá sản phẩm trên tiktok shop cách rút tiền hoa hồng tiktok shop cách xem doanh thu trên tiktok shop ads tiktok shop ảnh tiktok shop tài khoản tiktok shop bị hủy kích hoạt đơn hàng tiktok mua hàng tiktok trên máy tính mã cửa hàng tiktok shop voucher tiktok shop cách gắn giỏ hàng trên tiktok hoa hồng tiktok shop cách xác nhận đơn hàng trên tiktok shop đơn vị vận chuyển tiktok shop cách lấy link tiktok shop phí sàn tiktok shop tiktok shop giao hàng bao lâu tiktok cách kiếm tiền trên tiktok tiktok.com seller tiktok mã giảm giá tiktok hôm nay giao diện tiktok tiktok shop không hiện sản phẩm khiếu nại tiktok shop thêm sản phẩm vào tiktok shop thanh toán tiktok bằng momo cách trả hàng trên tiktok tiktok có cho kiểm hàng không cách xoá tiktok shop trả hàng hoàn tiền tiktok doanh thu tiktok shop tiktok shop icon cách hủy đơn hàng trên tiktok tiktok shop pc thuế tiktok shop cách liên kết tiktok shop cách xoá đánh giá trên tiktok mã giảm giá tiktok cho đơn hàng đầu tiên cách live bán hàng trên tiktok tax code tiktok là gì cách mở thanh toán khi nhận hàng trên tiktok cách làm affiliate tiktok mua kênh tiktok mã freeship tiktok thay đổi quốc gia trên tiktok shop hoa hồng affiliate tiktok tải tiktok seller về máy tính buff đơn tiktok mua acc tiktok máy in đơn tiktok tiktok shop ra đời khi nào cách xem thông tin khách hàng trên tiktok shop kháng nghị tiktok shop tiktok shop tuyển dụng cách kiếm tiền hoa hồng trên tiktok cách tạo giỏ hàng trên tiktok tiktok shop api chính sách bán hàng trên tiktok cách mua hàng trên tiktok được giảm giá khóa học tiktok tiktok seller center tiktok academy đăng sản phẩm lên tiktok shop bị đình chỉ nghiên cứu khoa học về tiktok shop không vào được tiktok shop cách livestream bán hàng trên tiktok trả hàng trên tiktok có mất phí không dịch vụ tiktok shop cách tạo tiktok shop trên máy tính quảng cáo tiktok shop cách gắn link sản phẩm trên tiktok cách đăng ký bán hàng trên tiktok tra cứu đơn hàng tiktok cách kiểm tra đơn hàng trên tiktok cách xây dựng kênh tiktok bán hàng cách sửa đánh giá trên tiktok shop cách đăng sản phẩm lên tiktok shop cách chạy quảng cáo tiktok cách xoá sản phẩm affiliate trên tiktok shop cách đăng thực phẩm chức năng lên tiktok shop tài khoản chính thức và tài khoản tiếp thị api tiktok chạy quảng cáo tiktok shop trên máy tính tài nguyên shop tiktok shop đăng nhập livestream tiktok giá trị biến thể là gì trên tiktok bán đồ ăn trên tiktok shop cách hủy đơn hàng trên tiktok đang chờ vận chuyển sách tiktok tài liệu tiktok shop cách vào tiktok shop bạn đã đạt đến giới hạn số lượng tài khoản có thể đăng ký tiktok shop seller center tiktok shop seller đăng nhập tiktok shop tạo tiktok shop cách đăng ký tiktok shop cách bán hàng trên tiktok shop mở tiktok shop 1 cccd đăng ký được bao nhiêu tiktok shop bán hàng trên tiktok shop tiktok shop là gì 1 cmnd đăng ký được mấy tài khoản tiktok shop logo tiktok shop tổng đài hỗ trợ tiktok shop tiếp thị liên kết tiktok shop tổng đài tiktok shop tải tiktok shop tiktok shop streamer desktop các từ bị cấm trên tiktok shop cách lập tiktok shop affiliate tiktok shop 1 cccd tạo được bao nhiêu tiktok shop cách tạo shop trên tiktok tạo tài khoản tiktok shop một cccd đăng ký được mấy tài khoản tiktok shop xoá tiktok shop cách đổi tên tiktok shop mua hàng trên tiktok shop cách mua hàng trên tiktok shop tạo shop trên tiktok mã tiktok shop tiktok shop mua hàng tiktok shop seller center vietnam hủy liên kết tiktok shop cách làm tiktok shop tiktok shop la gì mã giảm giá tiktok shop bán hàng tiktok shop phí sàn tiktok shop 2024 shopee express mã giảm giá shopee shopee food voucher shopee shopee affiliate shopeê tổng đài shopee shopee mall shopee kênh người bán shopee tuyển dụng affiliate shopee shopee seller tải shopee tra mã vận đơn shopee express shopee nghĩa ô gắn tag shopee live cách bán hàng trên shopee logo shopee bưu cục shopee express shopee express tracking mã freeship shopee proxy shopee shopee analytics tra mã vận đơn shopee tra mã đơn hàng shopee express mua nick shopee shopee mall là gì shopee express tuyển dụng shopee singapore kho sw soc shopee ở đâu shopee bán hàng gắn tag live shopee shopee express tra cứu cách săn sale shopee tra cứu shopee express tra cứu đơn hàng shopee shopee express mã vận đơn bưu cục shopee express gần đây shopee bán tra cứu đơn hàng shopee express tra cứu vận đơn shopee express shopee thailand nhanh shopee express shopee logo gắn link shopee live kênh người bán shopee voucher shopee hôm nay cách hủy đơn hàng trên shopee bán hàng trên shopee shopee voucher shopee express bưu cục hotline shopee shopee career shopee pay shopee seller center mã vận đơn shopee tra mã vận đơn standard express shopee mã giảm giá shopee hôm nay săn sale shopee shopee apk bán hàng trên shopee mất phí bao nhiêu mã giảm giá shopee cho mọi đơn hàng shopee xpress tổng đài shopee express phí sàn shopee lỗi m02 shopee spaylater shopee là gì mã shopee shopee live cách liên kết tài khoản ngân hàng với shopee pay mã voucher shopee kho bw soc shopee ở đâu shopee malaysia gắn live shopee shopee của nước nào xem tổng tiền đã mua trên shopee trên điện thoại tag live shopee kho shopee express cách trả hàng shopee kiểm tra đơn hàng shopee cách đặt hàng trên shopee seller shopee tag shopee live mã giới thiệu shopee cách xóa tài khoản shopee danh sách bưu cục shopee express mã voucher shopee hôm nay bán hàng shopee cách săn voucher shopee spaylater shopee có an toàn không tổng đài shopee miễn phí standard express shopee tra cứu vận đơn số dư tài khoản shopee tiếp thị liên kết shopee shopee bị lỗi cách mua hàng trên shopee taobao shopee cách đăng ký bán hàng trên shopee tra cứu mã vận đơn shopee spaylater shopee tải shopee pc sinh nhật shopee chăm sóc khách hàng shopee voucher shopee 0đ cảng pingxiang shopee ở đâu tuyển dụng shopee tải shopee trên máy tính m02 shopee magiamgia shopee shopee tracking cách hủy đơn hàng trên shopee khi đang giao shopee live pc đăng ký bán hàng trên shopee công ty shopee giao hàng shopee tài khoản shopee bị khóa shopee express gần đây săn mã freeship 0đ shopee hôm nay ảnh shopee lịch nghỉ tết shopee 2024 cskh shopee kho shopee nghĩa ô tra cứu mã vận đơn shopee express shopee wallet shopee thái lan shopee express tuyển dụng shipper shopee philippines cách tải shopee trên máy tính mã vận đơn shopee express tra cứu đơn shopee giảm giá shopee số dư tài khoản shopee là gì tải shopee về máy tính banner shopee số dư tài khoản shopee có mua hàng được không shopee merchant wallet shopee - tìm trên google shopee affiliate program seller own fleet tra cứu vận đơn shopee mã freeship shopee bannenbiet quảng cáo shopee tra mã shopee express hủy đơn shopee shopee food tuyển dụng mã shopee voucher thử thách shopee lỗi f02 shopee thời gian làm việc của shipper shopee express tra đơn shopee express tra cứu vận đơn shopee kol shopee link gắn tag shopee live chạy quảng cáo shopee đánh giá shopee tra số shipper shopee express live shopee xóa tài khoản shopee shopee merchant mã freeship shopee hôm nay mã đơn hàng shopee shopee ex mẫu đánh giá shopee lướt shopee nhận quà liên quân voucher freeship shopee khiếu nại shopee tuyển dụng shopee express cách làm tiếp thị liên kết shopee shopee nghĩa ô là ở đâu phí shopee hotline shopee express kho thâm quyến shopee ở đâu công ty tnhh shopee express cách làm affiliate shopee trả hàng hoàn tiền shopee tool gắn tag shopee live bưu cục shopee express hà nội tra đơn hàng shopee cách trả hàng trên shopee tài khoản shopee bị khóa f02 điểm gửi hàng shopee express tra cứu đơn shopee express mã giới thiệu kol shopee cách săn mã giảm giá shopee cách trả hàng trên shopee khi đã nhận hàng tang follow shopee vinalike cách tra số điện thoại shipper shopee express mã shopee hôm nay cách hủy đơn trên shopee ví trả sau shopee logo shopee png cách đăng ký bán hàng trên shopee bằng điện thoại tra vận đơn shopee express lịch nghỉ tết của shopee express 2024 văn mẫu đánh giá shopee huỷ đơn hàng shopee shopee express vận đơn seller own fleet - vận chuyển quốc tế shopee săn voucher shopee shopee sale shopee express hotline hotline shopee food tổng đài shopee food ví shopee pay là gì cách lấy mã giảm giá shopee phí thanh toán shopee gắn link live shopee cách liên kết tài khoản ngân hàng với shopee cách xem tổng số tiền đã mua trên shopee ví shopee shopee liên quân đăng ký shopee mall icon shopee cách làm kol shopee đăng ký kol shopee shopee analytic shopee icon đăng ký shopee food shopee shopee.vn app shopee indonesia shopee taiwan shopeepay spaylater là gì download video shopee spx tracking shopee food logo dropshipping shopee subaccount shopee partner flash sale shopee api email shopee shopee video cách khắc phục lỗi m02 shopee bw soc ở đâu shopee 11.11 liên kết thẻ tín dụng với shopeepay shopee tuyển dụng thực tập sinh link shopee merchant wallet lịch sale shopee black friday shopee ronaldo shopee cảng pingxiang game shopee shopee 6.6 shopee làm việc đến ngày nào thì nghỉ tết voucher shopee food seller own fleet standard express.com shopeefood tuyển dụng shopee xu

The city as a space of power and exclusion

ISCI is a cross-disciplinary research centre working to further our understanding of state crime: organisational deviance violating human rights

The city as a space of power and exclusion

Hot Docs

Dr Kristian Lasslett, Senior Lecturer in Criminology

3 May 2016

Introduction

Today The Opposition premieres at the coveted Hot Docs festival, after parrying systematic efforts to silence the film in the Australian courts. It documents arguably the most controversial real-estate venture in the history of Papua New Guinea (PNG), which centres on a 14 hectare tract of land in the nation’s capital known as Paga Hill.

The real-estate venture precipitated a five year struggle to save Paga Hill from the developer’s knife, which left in its wake mass demolitions, serious human rights abuses and allegations of transnational corruption.

However, this film is not only about Paga Hill or indeed PNG. It is a timely warning siren that challenges the audience to peer behind the cosmopolitan glamour of gentrification, and witness the creeping form of social cleansing hidden beneath.

It also takes on with unflinching courage the global nexus of political, financial and property interests standing behind real-estate speculation that has turned cities into casinos – playgrounds for the rich and powerful, while the poor serve the drinks and deal the cards. 

The trailer can be viewed here:

Paga Hill is not only an iconic PNG landmark, it is emblematic of a global process that is  forging urban dystopias. From London to Mumbai, cities are becomes spaces of exclusion, rather than inclusion; places that transforms not to the beat of human need, but to power in its rawest forms.

The Opposition shows with intimacy and penetrating clarity how power and the city function. By taking a forensic lens to the case of Paga Hill, we can therefore begin to understand the hidden dynamics at the heart of what Neil Brenner calls planetary urbanisation.

The Paga Hill Estate – A vision for a ‘progressive’ future 

Once designated a national park, the majestic surrounds of Paga Hill have been eyed by numerous real-estate developers over the years. However, it is the Paga Hill Development Company (PHDC) which succeeded in clearing the land of its residents and national park status.

This paved the way for a development that will evidently include luxury hotels, 800+ residential apartments, sporting facilities, marina precinct, and multi-use commercial precinct.

PHDC boasts, ‘with tourists and visitors staying at the Hilton Hotel, residents of the site, together with city visitors enjoying the waterfront retail, restaurants and marina complex, the area will be a buzzing melting pot, creating a new image for a progressive Papua New Guinea’ (Hilton Hotels strongly denies  any involvement in the project).

Even among the rubble produced by a brutal demolition exercise in 2012, the site’s development value is readily apparent.

Of course it is always important to ask, who in particular will benefit from the proposed real-estate venture? Rarely are such projects universally beneficial.

We at least know one core clientele. It was recently announced that the estate ‘will be the venue for the Leaders’ meetings at the Asia-Pacific Economic Co-operation summit in Port Moresby’ slated to take place in 2018.

This is one of the most important multilateral forums in the Asia-Pacific region. If this announcement is true – unlike the partnership with Hilton Hotels – this gives the venture a special strategic importance for the summit’s principal sponsors the PNG and Australian governments.

Although the construction timeframe looks tight, PHDC has announced that the Shenzhen based, Zhongtai company, will collaborate in the development, with Chinese government backing.

The project also evidently has the support of the National Capital District Commission and PNG’s national government. According to PHDC’s website the ‘PNG Government will provide the support through relaxation of import duties and taxes’.

However, over its twenty year lifespan what is perhaps most striking about the Paga Hill Estate is the project’s ability to weather controversy. In 2007 the Public Accounts Committee accused PHDC of acquiring the land through ‘corrupt dealings’.

Five years later the project hit the headlines again after residents faced a brutal demolition exercise, executed by the Royal PNG Constabulary, allegedly at the behest of the company. This event became iconic when the opposition leader, Dame Carol Kidu, was frogmarched from the scene by police officers who had used live ammunition on residents. She argued PHDC was not an appropriate company to be entrusted with Paga Hill (Kidu later retracted her statement, and entered into a consultancy contract with PHDC).

In October 2012 matters got worse when it was reveal that PHDC’s CEO, Gudmundur Fridriksson, has managed or owned businesses censured in investigations conducted by the Public Accounts Committee, the Auditor General’s Office and the Commission of Inquiry into the Department of Finance – seven in total.

The details were covered extensively by the Australian media, although sadly little of the controversy made its way into PNG’s muzzled press. That said, PNG citizens have created a vibrant social media alternative, which became a vital hub for circulating information on Paga Hill.

A month after this expose Fridriksson took leave from an Australian government funded think-tank where he was CEO, evidently to pursue business interests in PNG. His presence has now been wiped entirely from their website.

The wife of prominent Australian indigenous lawyer Noel Pearson – the latter is a key figure behind the think-tank – then disinvested of her shares in PHDC during January 2013.

Despite the turbulence, Papua New Guinea’s O’Neill Government has time and time again rallied behind the venture. Ministers have issued supportive press statements, the government real-estate firm NHEL  agreed to partner in the project on a 50/50 basis, and the development is now receiving generous tax breaks.

This is nothing new, from the project’s very inception in 1996 the executives pushing this luxury estate have proven adept at garnering support from some of PNG’s most powerful political forces.

A rejected planning application and Michael Nali MP

The first major challenge to getting the project off the ground was rezoning the land at Paga Hill and obtaining an Urban Development Lease. Back then it was the Paga Hill Land Holding Company (PHLHC) – a precursor to the Paga Hill Development Company – which led the way.

According to Investment Promotion Authority records – Papua New Guinea’s corporate registry – its shareholders included Rex Paki, Felix Leyagon, and the Western Australian company, Fidelity Management Pty Ltd. Its Directors were Rex Paki and Gudmundur Fridriksson.

Fridriksson used the same Perth address as Fidelity Management Pty Ltd in records he submitted to the Investment Promotion Authority for Asigau (PNG) Holdings Limited, a company he owned with his wife, Tau Fridriksson. Initially the landholding company’s Secretary was Tau Fridriksson, according to Investment Promotion Authority records she was replaced on 1 July 1998 by Rex Paki.

VIS_Fidelity Ltd PTy-1458982952576

 

Clearly a  key player during the project’s start-up period was the Shareholder-Director-Secretary, Rex Paki, who was also the principal of Port Moresby firm Ram Business Consultants. Ram would go on to collect its own share of official condemnation from the Commission of Inquiry into the National Provident Fund, in addition to Public Accounts Committee and Auditor Generals Office investigations.

Despite having up and coming executives at the helm, PHLHC’s initial proposal for a luxury estate at Paga Hill was rejected by the Physical Planning Board in late 1996. The board noted, ‘proper procedures in relation to the processing of Planning applications were not followed’. This seemingly put an onion in the ointment, unless the application was approved, and the land rezoned, the Land Board could not lawfully issue an Urban Development Lease.

However, the company received a major boost in 1997, when its proposal obtained the backing of Michael Nali, the Minister for Civil Aviation, Culture and Tourism.  On 27 February 1997 he wrote to PHLHC stating: ‘It give [sic] me pleasure to confirm my full support to your proposed comprehensive mixed use development of Paga Hill … I am prepared to sponsor a submission to the National Executive Council [Cabinet] next month to have the project endorsed as a property of National Significance. It deserves the full support of Papua New Guinea’.

23. 1997 2 25 Michael Nali National Significance Letter1

Subsequently, Michael Nali acquired a 9% stake in PHLHC’s successor vehicle the Paga Hill Development Company (PHDC) through Kwadi Inn Limited, which Nali is the sole owner of. However, it should be underlined this occurred in December 2011. By then Nali had lost office.

Yet the importance of Nali’s involvement in 2011 can’t be underestimated. A towering figure from Papua New Guinea’s Southern Highlands, Nali is in business with some of the nation’s most powerful individuals.

Take the example of NIU Finance Limited. According to Investment Promotion Authority records [PDF], Nali’s company Kwadi Inn obtained a significant stake in this company during 2009, joining a select cast of executives and investors.

According to its last Annual Return, the company’s Managing Director is Peter O’Neill, Papua New Guinea’s Prime Minister.  Peter O’Neill again appears as the largest shareholder in NIU, through his companies LBJ Investments Limited, and Paddy’s Hotel & Apartments Limited. Another notable shareholder in this enterprise is Piskulic Limited, a company wholly owned by Ken Fairweather, Member of Parliament for Sumkar.

There is no evidence on the public record to suggest either O’Neill or Fairweather have been involved in the Paga Hill Estate. Nevertheless, it is clear Nali circulates in powerful business circles.

And it goes further than this. It appears that Nali had direct business links with PHLHC’s Rex Paki and Felix Leyagon dating back to 1996-1997, the period when he agreed to sponsor the Paga Hill development as a project of national significance in Cabinet.

According to company records kept by the Investment Promotion Authority, on 11 November 1996, a company Waim No.54 Limited, was incorporated. Its two Directors were Rex Paki and Felix Leyagon. The company also had two equal shareholders, the Tourism Minister, Michael Nali and Mary Nali.

In addition to this, Waim No.54 Limited’s registered address was Ram Business Consultants, ADF Haus, Ground Floor, Musgrave Street, Port Moresby, National Capital District, Papua New Guinea. This is the same registered address employed by PHLHC.

If accurate, IPA records suggest Rex Paki and Felix Leyagon were Directors at a company owned by Michael and Mary Nali. Furthermore, Michael Nali’s company, Waim No.54, also shared PHLHC’s registered address.

During this same period, Michael Nali, in his Ministerial capacity agreed to sponsor PHLHC’s proposed Paga Hill property development in Cabinet as a project of national significance, a venture  in which Rex Paki and Felix Leyagon were shareholders, with executive involvement from Gudmundur Fridriksson and Paki.

VIS_Paga Hill ownership and Nali 2-1458984042720

Public Accounts Committee alleges ‘corrupt dealings’

Of course, it cannot be deduced from these facts that the above parties were involved in any wrongdoing. However, in light of a subsequent Public Accounts Committee inquiry, which alleged that the land at Paga Hill was secured by PHLHC through ‘corrupt dealings’, this new link raises questions.

Underpinning the Public Accounts Committee’s concern was the circumstances under which the lease was obtained. For instance the Urban Development Lease was awarded to PHLHC when the land was still zoned open space. Before she recanted, Dame Carol Kidu observed this was in violation of the Land Act 1996, section 67, which declares, ‘a State lease shall not be granted for a purpose that would be in contravention of zoning requirements under the Physical Planning Act 1989, any other law relating to physical planning, or any law relating to the use, construction or occupation of buildings or land’.

Subsequently, PHDC was awarded a full 99 year Business Lease, despite the fact the improvement covenant set out in the Urban Development Lease was not completed as required.

The Public Accounts Committee claimed  it was not surprised this covenant remained unactioned. It observed, ‘the Lessee cannot pay the Land Rental and has sought relief from that obligation, much less fund a development of the magnitude required’.

31. 1998 4 6 PHDC UDL

However, apparently this is not the only occasion that a company connected with Ram Business Consultants is alleged to have been involved in illegal land dealings. Those familiar with the Commission of Inquiry into the National Provident Fund Chaired by Judge Tos Barnett,  may have had a touch of déjà vu when the name Waim was mentioned.

Ram Business Consultants, Waim No.92 and the NPF Commission of Inquiry

It was another holding company, Waim No.92 Pty Ltd, that was allegedly used to defraud the National Provident Fund – a transaction that saw one conspirator sentenced to six years imprisonment with hard labour. According to the Commission of Inquiry, controversial PNG businessman Jimmy Maladina was the ‘secret owner of Waim No.92 Pty Ltd the shares of which he initially owned through his wife Janet Karl, and an accountant Phillip Eludeme. Ms Karl’s share was later transferred to Phillip Mamando who resided at the Mr Maladina’s residence’.

The Commission of Inquiry alleges that ‘Mr Maladina was responsible for bribing Land Board chairman Ralph Guise and Lands Minister Viviso Seravo, to ensure Waim No.92 was granted the lease of the Waigani Land on very favourable terms’. It continues: ‘The records of the Land Board indicate it notified Waim No. 92 that it had been recommended as the successful applicant and on September 28, 1998, Waim No. 92 received notice that a corruptly reduced purchase price of K1,724,726.10 was payable before title would issue, with annual rent to be K17,000 (instead of the legally correct amounts of K2,866,000 and K143,000 respectively)’.

The Commission of Inquiry claims that Waim No.92 frontman Philip Eludeme acted as a key fixer, ‘prior to the Land Board hearing, Mr Eludeme had approached Minister Seravo seeking favourable consideration for Waim No. 92’s application and, at Mr Seravo’s request, had performed, free of charge, accountancy services for Minister Seravo valued at K100,000’.

According to the company’s annual returns for 1998, Waim No.92’s  registered office during this period was Ram Business Consultants, ADF House. While its two shareholders cited above, Philip Eludeme and Phillip Mamando, similarly list their registered office as Ram Business Consultants, ADF House.

During 1998 Maladina’s alleged fixer, Philip Eludeme, was a director of the company Sulawei Limited, along with PHLHC shareholder, Felix Leyagon. Sulawei Limited’s  registered address was again Ram Business Consultants, ADF House.

VIS_PHLHC and NPF-1459101329941

It would thus appear there were multiple links between two networks alleged to have been involved in similar style illicit land deals by the Public Accounts Committee and the Commission of Inquiry into the National Provident Fund, respectively.

The Paki Fridriksson split and the Inquiry into the Office of the Public Curator  

The original development vehicle was of course the PHLHC. However, the Auditor General notes in early 2000 its two Directors apparently part ways [PDF], with Gudmundur Fridriksson evidently leaving Ram Business Consultants where he was alleged to have been employed (Fridriksson is PHDC’s current CEO).

Fridriksson was then involved in setting up a number of companies including Anvil Legal Services Limited, Anvil Project Services (PNG) Limited, Anvil Commodities and Trading Limited, Anvil Marine Limited, Anvil Marketing Consultants Limited, and CCS Anvil Limited.

Anvil Project Services (PNG) Limited and CCS Anvil Limited  have been censured in the course of  inquiries conducted by the Auditor General, Public Accounts Committee and the Commission of Inquiry into the Department of Finance. Perhaps the most controversial of these companies is Anvil Project Services (PNG) Limited,  which was awarded lucrative consultancy contracts with the Public Curator’s Office (shortly after Ram Business Consultants lost its contract with the same office).

This award wade made despite the fact the arrangement had been rejected by the Central Supply and Tender Board owing to no public tender – a procedure which is in violation of Papua New Guinea’s Public Finances (Management) Act 1995.

The contract went ahead anyway, although it is alleged [PDF] by the Public Accounts Committee and Auditor General, that payments were made out of private estates held on trust by the Public Curator.

According to company records kept at the Investment Promotion Authority, Gomoga Jack Nouairi, the Acting Public Curator at the time which the Public Curator and Anvil began working together, had a 30% stake in Anvil Project Services (PNG) Limited – the remaining 70% was owned by Gudmundur Fridriksson and his wife through the company Asigau (PNG) Holdings Limited.

Nouairi was also Director of Anvil Commodities and Trading Limited, in which Anvil Project Services (PNG) Limited had a 50% stake, and was a 50% owner of Anvil Legal Services Limited, along with Gudmundur and Tau Fridriksson.

VIS_Public Curators Office-1462274910214 copy

Another company implicated in the inquiry into the Public Curator’s Office was Jac’o Business Consultants Limited, a concern owned by its principal Jack Naiyep. Despite being paid K1.5 million by the Public Curator’s Office, the Public Accounts Committee claims ‘there was no evidence that any formal procurement had ever taken place, nor was there any evidence of any formal contract’.

Naiyep and the Fridrikssons were business partners in a separate company they co-owned together, Anvil Business Services Limited.  Naiyep also had a stake in Mamaku Mai No.3 Limited. Before the latter company was deregistered it was connected to the family of former Prime Minister Bill Skate.  Also of significance is one of the company’s Directors, Paul Wagun.

It was a Paul Wagun who replaced Gomoga Jack Nouairi as Public Curator, and submitted evidence to the Public Accounts Committee and Taskforce Sweep contesting any wrongdoing by his office or Anvil (PNG) Project Services Limited. It cannot be confirmed this is the same Paul Wagun, however, given Jac’o Consultant’s role in the Public Curator’s Office, the overlap is concerning.

Sadly in a subsequent inquiry into this affair by Papua New Guinea’s anti-corruption agency, Investigation Taskforce Sweep, none of these crucial links between Fridriksson, Nouairi, Naiyep and Wagun were acknowledged in its case report, despite being freely obtainable from the Investment Promotion Authority company registry. When these flaws were noted by this author in a report published last year, Investigation Taskforce Sweep threatened to sue for defamation.

Another interesting company set up during this period under the Anvil stable, was Anvil Marine Limited. During its period of operation 2002-2005, the company was owned by Gudmundur and Tau Fridriksson, along with the father and son team, Tom Amaiu and Labi Alex Amaiu. Tom Amaiu is a former Member of Parliament, who was sentenced to five years prison for theft.

His son Labi Amaiu is the current Member of Parliament for Moresby North East, and has patronised PHDC, featuring prominently in the company’s promotional material. He can be seen in this video published by PHDC lauding Gudmundur Fridriksson. Amaiu states he would like to ‘congratulate and thank the CEO of Paga Hill development for a successful venture, this is what we call legacy, and I am proud to be part of that legacy’.

Fridriksson’s companies featured in a number of other inquiries during this contentious period, including the Commission of Inquiry into the Department of Finance. Nevertheless, public condemnation from Papua New Guinea’s anti-corruption agencies has not significantly impacted on PHDC’s grip over the land at Paga Hill.

Paga Hill Development Company’s Southern Highlands Connection

Part of PHDC’s success appears to be linked to its influential stakeholders. It will be recalled that the Urban Development Lease was originally awarded to PHLHC, a company jointly owned by Rex Paki, Felix Leyagon and Fidelity Management Pty Ltd. When the lease was converted into a 99 year Business Lease in 2000, the owner was a new corporate vehicle, PHDC.

The Public Accounts Committee in its inquiry drew attention to this – the recipient of any converted lease, it argued, should have been the initial owner PHLHC. At the time, PHDC was owned by Fidelity Management Ltd Pty, a holding company which shared a registered address in Perth, Australia with Gudmundur Fridriksson. But unlike PHLHC, Rex Paki and Felix Leyagon were not on the share register.

In 2005 ownership of the company changed hands, as Fidelity Management Ltd Pty’s shares were transferred to another vehicle,  Anvil Holding Limited. At this time Anvil Holdings Limited was owned by George Hallit, along with Gudmundur and Tau Fridriksson. However, between 2008 and 2011 there were a series of further changes to PHDC’s ownership structure. By the end of it, the Fridrikssons’ apparently divested all their shares in the company. It was PHDC’s lawyer, Stanley Liria, who became the majority shareholder.

Originally from the Southern Highlands, Liria has published a number of legal texts.  The first was launched in 2005 by Southern Highlands political heavyweight Peter O’Neill who informed the Post-Courier he would recommend to his ‘parliament colleagues that they buy the newly published book’.

Liria is also commercially linked to a number of high profile Southern Highland politicians. For instance, Liria is Director of Southern Highlands Holding Limited, along with former Minister, Michael Nali, who is also a PHDC shareholder via Kwadi Inn Limited. The sole shareholder of the holding company is the Southern Highlands Provincial Government.

In addition, there is Sharp Hills Investment Limited, a company fully owned by Southern Highlands Governor William Tipi, who entered parliament as an MP for Peter O’Neill’s People’s National Congress party. According to Sharp Hill’s company records, its registered office is Liria Lawyers, a firm which Stanley Liria is the principal of. William Tipi was also formerly a shareholder in Southern Highlands Holding Limited, presumably as a trustee for the provincial government.

Alongside Liria at PHDC is Michael Nali, who through Kwadi Inn, has acquired a 9% stake in the company – although this was reduced to 2% during April 2016. As we have already observed, Nali is in business with Papua New Guinea’s most powerful political players including Prime Minister O’Neill.

Curiously absent though is Gudmundur Fridriksson. Despite being the principal visionary and driver behind the project he has seemingly divested from the company, while retaining an executive role as CEO.

Nevertheless, given the current political gravity in Papua New Guinea, having backers with strong Southern Highlands credentials cannot have harmed the company over the past five years, as it has navigated significant public resistance to its real-estate venture.

Cold comfort 

All this analysis is rather academic for former Paga Hill residents. Many had their homes, belongings, church and school destroyed through a number of demolition exercises between 2012-2014 (PHDC has only been directly linked to the first exercise in May 2012). The soul and life of the community is captured in a moving song they composed to commemorate the destruction:

As a result of the demolition exercise, the site is now being prepared for the luxury estate which Michael Nali lauded as Minister back in 1997. Twenty years on, as the development is promoted as a host site for APEC 2018, questions still linger over the land transactions that underpinned its inception and a number of  executives involved in stewarding this project.

Given the systematic efforts being devoted to censoring a documentary film covering this controversial ventureone senses these questions may encroach on very powerful interests indeed.

injunction

Yet whatever happens with Paga Hill, audiences may sense the bell tolls for thee. As a real-estate venture Paga Hill is not unique or exceptional, even if its displaced residents are a very special group indeed.

Around the world cities are transforming through a process of creative destruction, or what geographer David Harvey calls accumulation by dispossession. They are becoming spaces moulded in the image of power, money, corruption and violence.

Indeed, the technical and often highly opaque character of urban governance is a breeding ground for abuse and inequality. It is a matter for wonks, bureaucrats and developers. It needs to be a space of popular, public participation.

The Opposition calls this to our attention. Of course, what we do to confront these dilemmas is the next urgent conversation to be had.