phim sex vlxx sex viet sex vietsub phim sex vietsub phimsexsub phim sex nhật bản phim xxx phimsex sex hay phim sex hay sexvietsub jav vietsub sex sub phim xex phim sex sub phim sex mới haysex phim se phim sex mới nhất javsub heo69 sex viet sub sexsub phim sex viet sub sex vietsud phim sex vlxx sex nhật không che vlxyz sex3x phim người lớn jav sub phim sex vietsud phim sex việt sub phim x phim sex phụ đề phim sex vietsub không che xxx việt phim s sex vietsup sex vietsub không che sex phim phim sex vietsup vlxx.com phim sex moi phímex fim sex sex viétub viet sex sex việt sub phim sex. phim sex nhật không che phím sex vlxx. javphim phim sex viétub xxx vietsub phim se x phim sex phu de vlxc phim sex viêt sex không che vietsub xxx nhật phim sex moi nhat vlxx.sex xxx viet phimsex vietsub vkxx phim sex loạn luân nhật bản phim sex không che vietsub javvietsub sex châu âu vietsub phim sexsub phimsexsud phimsexvietsub phim sex xxx phin sex vlzx phim sex vl sex vietsub ko che jav việt sex vietsub khong che xem phim sex vietsub sex nhật vietsub phim sex vietsub khong che lvxx sex trung sub jav phim phim set my phim+sex phim sex viet sup sẽ việt phim sex việt mới nhất phum sex jav nhật sex viet sup phim set nhat ban phim sexvietsub vlxz jav mới phim sex việt nam phim sex viet nam phim sex trung quốc phim sex vn phim sex không che phim sex việt phim sex mỹ phim sex hàn quốc phim sex anime phim sex viet phim sex loạn luân phim sex nhật phim sex ko che phim sex loan luan phim sex thái lan xem phim sex phim sex gái xinh phim sex hiếp dâm phim sex châu âu phim sex khong che phim sex việt nam mới nhất phim sex hồng kông phim sex gay phim sex trần hà linh phim sex online phim sex vietnam phim sex trung quoc phim sex cổ trang xem phim sex việt nam phim sex hoạt hình phim sex trung phim sex học sinh phim sex bố chồng nàng dâu phim sex my phim sex jav phim sex china phim sex thủ dâm phim sex nhật bản không che coi phim sex phim sex phá trinh phim sex hd phim sex tập thể phim sex đài loan phim sex hàn phim sex thái phim sex ấn độ phim sex nhat ban phim sex hentai phim sex vú to phim sex nhat phim sex top 1 phim sex k che phim sex việt nam không che phim sex massage phim sex phương mỹ chi phim sex vụng trộm phim sex quay lén phim sex âu mỹ phim sex hay nhất phim sex cô giáo thảo phim sex viêt nam phim sex bà già phim sex mẹ con phim sex live phim sex địt nhau coi phim sex việt nam phim sex máy bay bà già phim sex cấp 3 phim sex han quoc phim sex nga phim sex việt nam mới phim sex bú lồn phim sex phim sex phim sex linh miu phim sex hiep dam phim sex top1 phim sex mbbg phim sex 2024 phim sex viet nam moi nhat phim sex việt nam có tiếng phim sex trung quốc vietsub phim sex gai xinh sex việt sex việt nam sex vn sex viet nam phim heo địt nhau sex không che sexviet sex ko che clip sex phim 18+ sexx phim sẽ sex vietnam phim set phim 18 phim xet sex jav dit nhau phim xx phim địt nhau sex mới phim sec phim xes sex k che sex khong che sex nhat sayuri hayama phim con heo phim sexx xxx vn phim xec đit nhau sexhay jav không che xxx việt nam sex viêt sex việt mới xem sex sex moi phim dit nhau clip sex việt sexxx phim xét sex việt mới nhất phim18 phimloz phim set viet nam vlxxx clip sex viet phimset sex trung quốc vietsub xxx ko che clip sex vn jav ko che phim sét clip sex viet nam sex việt nam! xxx không che sex nhật bản không che xemphimsextv phimxx sex viêt nam sex anime ko che phim vlxx sex mới nhất phim sex.com sex vlxx dmsex sex video sex địt nhau video sex phim xxxx xem địt nhau sex anime không che sex trung vietsub sex viet moi đụ nhau sex kh che sex 18+ xem phim địt nhau sex hihi sexmup sex phụ đề jav khong che tải phim sex sex nhật ko che xxx trung sex việt hay phim 18 + phimsexvietnam sex việt nam mới địt nhau không che phim heo vn xem sex việt nam phim set vn se x phim xex việt nam sex online clip sex mới nhất phim ses jav.hd sex vn mới nhất hayama sayuri phimsec sex việt nam không che không che phim set việt nam phim sex có phụ đề sex sex phim sẽ vn phim sech phim sex 18+ sexmoi phim sexxx chịch việt nam xxx viet nam sex viet hay sex viẹt sex đẹp sex gái sexx vn sex link clip sex mới phim sex nước ngoài sex viet moi nhat phim xxx việt nam chiếu phim sex phim sez phimsexviet phim xes việt nam sex vl phim nguoi lon sexgai sex v phimsexhay phim sex hàn quốc không che sexhayvc link sex mới phim xéc sex 18 xem phim sex không che phim sex loạn luân không che phim sex anime không che phim sẽ việt nam phim xét việt nam phim xxx vn phim 18+ vietsub phimsexhd123 xvideos3 xem phim sex hàn quốc sexsot vlxx việt nam sex viet mới phim sex việt mới phim sex vn mới nhất dịt nhau xnxx xxx xvideo pornhub xvideos porn hub xhamster xxnx xnx xxx video xhamter sex xxx xvideo.com xnxx.com xvideos.com xvdeo x video pornhud pornhup xnxxxx pronhub xvdeos xham video xxx poỏn videoxxx sex porn xnxx com porhub xnxn porn hud deepfake porn xxx my xxx.com xnxc pornhun nxxx sex.com xvide sex videos sextube xnxx. sex movie xxx sex viet69 cliphotvn link sex viet 69 sexvn sex việt nam mới nhất lộ clip sex việt 69 clipsex sex nhanh viet69.net clip sex hot sex viet 88 viet69. sex lộ link địt nhau việt nam phim heo việt nam cliphot vn clipphot sex viet88 sex lộ clip sex trung quốc sex anime sex trung sex nhật sex châu âu sex trần hà linh sex gái xinh sex gay sex mỹ live sex sex china sex nhật bản anime sex sex thủ dâm sex top 1 sex hàn quốc sex cosplay sex loạn luân trần hà linh sex sex hàn sex live sex học sinh sex trung quoc sex top1 sex hiếp dâm sex my truyện tranh sex ảnh sex sex education sex quay lén sex vú to sex hd sex âu mỹ sex 3d sex hà linh sex cổ trang sex nhat ban sex tq sex hentai clip sex việt nam sex thái lan sex loan luan sex tập thể truyện sex sex tran ha linh sex linh miu sex phá trinh sex mbbg gay sex clip sex trần hà linh sex hoạt hình sex chau au sex tối cổ sex gai xinh cosplay sex sex top sex phương mỹ chi sex les sex toy sex sinh viên chat sex sex doggy roblox sex game sex sex gay anime anh sex sex nga sex massage sex 2k9 sex thái sex âu sex vụng trộm sex bú cu sex chibi sex tây sex roblox clip sex phương mỹ chi clip sex hiền hồ sex one piece sex hiền hồ sex gái xinh trung quốc sex 2k8 sex mẹ con sex china news sex teen sex loli sex thu dam massage sex sex gái xinh việt nam sex anna gấu xxvideo xvideo98 xvideo69 xxxvideo xvideos98 sex 69 xvideos99 xxvideos videox phim sex miễn phí sex moi nhat xvideo99 phim sex v xes việt nam xvideo vn phim sex xx video sex việt nam phim sex nhật bản mới nhất xxxvideos sex nhau sex bắn tùm lum sex vn 2023 svideox xvideovietnam xvideo việt nam sex98 xvideos69 xvideos 98 xvideox xxx videos free porn xem sex viet nam phim sex cực hay jav javhd missav thisav javhay jav hd njav javhiv phim jav javhdhay this av jav hay jav sex sexnhat hentai sextop1 hentaiz stripchat tuoi69 sextop chịch spankbang gái xinh thủ dâm fake taxi thiendia hentai 3d anime hentai rule 34 xxxx checkerviet sexdiary chibi1311 sieukhung taxi fake sweetie fox hentai ko che strip chat gái thủ dâm yua mikami bú lồn hentai.z móc lồn supjav truyện tranh hentai anime chịch hentai anime hentai one piece phimxxx melody mark rule34 phim hentai thanhlau anime 18+ lau xanh hentai z hen tai xxx anime lồn đẹp chịch anime melody marks sục cu hentai genshin sục cặc xxxxx anime xxx xnxxx thumbzilla one piece hentai mina kitano anny walker tran ha linh xemphimgay emi fukada hentai gay bdsm gái việt thủ dâm roblox r34 elle lee eva elfie china av xxx trung quốc gay porn phim cấp 3 game hentai lồn múp chịch gái xinh vnxx hentaizz hanime phimheo học sinh thủ dâm chaturbate henta hentai naruto anime địt nhau mia khalifa clipsexviet liếm lồn anime r34 youtubecliphot xlxx phá trinh chich nhau phim18hd blackpink r34 bóp vú ihentai hentai vn shen nana eimi fukada misav sxnm minami aizawa boyfriendtv javgg chinababe hentai manhwa rei kamiki full clip hot 3xchina momo sakura hongkongdoll miuzxc onlyfan leak sex diary lauxanh lilyxoxoles ai sayama manhwa hentai javful sex onlyfan nagi hikaru hentai manga genshin impact hentai rosie rider sex 2024 hentai game brazzers travelvids ixxx sexgay genshin hentai tiktok sex hentai nami sexvietnam sex gái xinh vn karen yuzuriha ssis-469 hentaix ssis 469 hentai ntr xmxx trần hà linh lộ clip gái xinh sex sexchauau jav việt nam trần hà linh xxx sex hack cam sextrungquoc tran ha linh sex phim sex chau au show lồn sex vn mới sex 2k6 phim sex tran ha linh sex bạn thân phim sex việt nam 2024 sex việt 2024 địt em gái sex máy bay xxx trần hà linh sextrung sex mẹ pim sex livestream sex rausex sex ha linh sex livestream clip tran ha linh suchibi trang sex sex viet 2024 phim xet viet nam sex viet nam moi nhat clip sex tran ha linh sex bé tôm sex 69vn buomtv subjav xxphim ihentaiz phimkk tiengruoi hihisex miu shiramine tut4k loạn luân xnxx vn xex loan luan quay len xxphe phim sẽ gầy miu shiromine quattv phim18d saika kawakita clip sex mi trần gai gu sex siêu nhân fukada ditnhau chịch gái nxx sex bạo dâm xxn sex hs vn sex hoc sinh sex hs mi trần sex 69vn.com xxx học sinh remu suzumori saoke ririko kinoshita mary tachibana phim loan luan sex mẹ kế phim cap 3 kana momonogi xxnxx sex some loanluan lonkk lồn to vungtrom xxx gái xinh sex em gái hikaru nagi học sinh chịch nhau xxx mỹ mikami yua chịch học sinh sex hiep dam thudam sex mông to làm tình rikka ono sex móc lồn sex cô giáo karen kaede chịch em gái phim sex mỹ đen phim sex mẹ kế arina hashimoto mio ishikawa mikami heo 69 link sex vn phim sex sinh viên sexnhanh hikari aozora thienvadia gai thu dam sex thu sex tap the sex69 phim sex loạn luân việt nam phim sex loan luan me con meguri javhd. sex bố chồng nàng dâu mei itsukaichi phim sex campuchia uno kanaya emi fukuda ryo ayumi yuna ogura liên quân r34 yu shinoda hình sex maki hojo thiendia88 mayuki ito phim sex gái đẹp ảnh nude hay88 tsukasa aoi sex hot gái xinh bú cu sex rên phim loạn luân sex vung trom jav69 phim đit nhau sex melody mark sex nami phim18+ ria yamate sex hồng kông địt gái xinh konan koyoi jav vn thủ dâm sex my readingmanga phim sex hiếp dâm tập thể sex pi tiên sẽ gầy không che suzu honjo phim sex vung trom sex loạn luân việt nam em gái thủ dâm phim xnxx phim sex hoc sinh phim sex sinh viên việt nam sex mĩ phim sex bà bầu vung trom live thủ dâm phim sex siêu nhân aoi ichino truyện sex gay sex vợ chồng sex gái đẹp eimi fukada sex hentai hiếp dâm vlzz sex thủ dâm vn emifukada phim sex les sex eimi fukada phim sex bú cu sex vú bự quay lén gái tắm sex sinh viên việt nam mỷeadingmanga yui hatano phim sex u50 phim sex loan luân quay lén tắm javhf phim sex tự sướng phim sex kh che vung trom.com xnnx phim sex education season 4 release date truyen sex sexmy phim sex bạo dâm riho fujimori yumi kazama dam69 jav k che sex đài loan mei washio clip xxx sex au my linh miu sex xxxvn phim sex vú bự sex cưỡi ngựa phim sex cha chồng nàng dâu rina ishihara sex melody ai kano sex2023 sẽ gầy ko che địt nhau vn maron natsuki thegioisex phim hiếp dâm yua mikami sex sex múp tube8 link sex việt nam amiri saitou coi phim sex hàn quốc vlxx com vlxx nghĩa là gì vlxx trung quốc vlxx viet nam vlxx vietsub vlxx không che vlxx vn vlxx việt sex vip tai phim sex web sex heo.vl phimxet sex. sexhd link sex mới nhất phimxes sex heo xem phim heo phim xech vlxx.moe sex nhât vl.xx xxvl phímexx xvlxx blxx mở phim sex phim sẽc seex phim sêx xexx xem xex phim séc phim xếch phim sex.net phimsexx phimx phin set xemphimsex phim sex vip sêx xem phim xec phim.set pim set phim sec nhat ban phim tình dục sexxxxx vlxx.tv phim sex heo wed sex phim seex vxll xem phim sex online phim sx trang phim sex xem phim xet phimsex.com phim dex clip sexx phm sex cho coi phim sex phim sex cosplay phim sex 2023 phim sex hà linh phim sex đam mỹ phim sex đồng tính nữ phim sex chibi phim sex gái xinh việt nam phim sex gái xinh trung quốc phim sex tq phim sex hiền hồ phim sex châu phi phim sex trung quốc không che phim sex học sinh việt nam phim sex máy bay bà già việt nam phim sex việt nam hay nhất phim sex hong kong phim sex người mẫu phim sex top sex vn hs phim sex ngoại tình sex ngoại tình phimxxx.vin Phim sex hay Phim sex Vietsub Phim sex không che Sex hiếp dâm Sex học sinh Vụng trộm - Ngoại tình Phim cấp 3 Sex Mỹ - Châu Âu XVIDEOS XNXX JAV XXX kiếm tiền online TikTok Shop Seller Center TikTok Shop Bán hàng online Cách đăng ký TikTok Shop tiktok seller seller tiktok seller center tiktokseller tiktokshop tiktok seller center fb shop affiliate tiktok tiktok shop tiktok shop seller center tiktok shop seller đăng ký tiktok shop tiktok shop đăng nhập cách tạo tiktok shop cách mở tiktok shop đăng nhập tiktok shop lazada seller center lazada lazada seller lazada seller center seller lazada lazada vietnam mã giảm giá lazada seller center lazada lazada center lazada tuyển dụng voucher lazada lazada vn lazada kênh người bán tổng đài lazada logo lazada tải lazada lazada affiliate lazada logo lazada seller đăng nhập lazada mall lazada việt nam lazada mua sắm lazada bán hàng lazada logistics lazada bán mã giảm giá lazada hôm nay bán hàng trên lazada lazada của nước nào cách bán hàng trên lazada cách hủy đơn hàng trên lazada ma giam gia lazada hotline lazada lazada career lazada center seller mã lazada lazada express affiliate lazada hoàn tiền lazada lazada philippines lazada group mã freeship lazada lazada malaysia sinh nhật lazada lazada seller centre tuyển dụng lazada lazada khuyen mai lazada thailand hoàn tiền mua sắm lazada lazada 11.11 lex vn seller own fleet tra cứu vận đơn tắt quảng cáo trên điện thoại samsung tra mã vận đơn lex vn kiểm tra đơn hàng lazada tra mã vận đơn lazada ahamove tracking lazada.vn đăng nhập mã giảm giá lazada cho người mới nhập mã giảm giá lazada lịch sử giá shopee đăng ký bán hàng trên lazada điểm gửi hàng lazada điểm gửi hàng lazada gần đây công ty lazada hủy đơn hàng lazada phí sàn lazada lazada hoàn tiền vào đâu lazada tuyển dụng giao hàng trả hàng lazada rút gọn link check giá shopee tong dai lazada gậy ba khúc lazada singapore lazada tphcm vib lazada cách đặt hàng trên lazada cách trả hàng lazada liên hệ lazada cách trả hàng trên lazada tra cứu đơn hàng lazada cách mua hàng trên lazada sinh nhat lazada trụ sở lazada sale lazada lừa đảo lazada đăng ký gian hàng lazada hoàn tiền max lazada thời gian hoàn tiền lazada lazada run tra cứu vận đơn cainiao lazada trả hàng hoàn tiền lazada xóa tài khoản lazada shopee và lazada của nước nào tra cứu điểm gửi hàng lazada trả góp lazada đơn vị vận chuyển lazada tiếp thị liên kết lazada tạo gian hàng trên lazada ảo ma canada khung shopee cách sử dụng xu trên lazada lazada indonesia lazada apk lazada run 2024 kho lazada tuyển dụng shopee cắt giảm nhân sự lazada api voucher hoàn tiền lazada la gì giao hàng lazada cách dùng xu lazada chạy quảng cáo lazada cách săn sale trên lazada tuyển dụng giao hàng lazada tphcm hủy liên kết momo với lazada lazada affiliate là gì liên kết momo với lazada cách sử dụng voucher hoàn tiền lazada sinh nhật lazada ngày nào sinh nhật lazada ngày mấy lazada affiliate program kho lazada lex vn ở đâu lazada live banner lazada black friday lazada đăng ký affiliate lazada cách kiếm tiền trên lazada cách sử dụng voucher tích lũy lazada hỗ trợ lazada địa điểm nhận hàng lex vn xử lý đơn hàng lazada tiktok shop tiktok seller đăng ký tiktok shop cách tạo tiktok shop tiktok shop partner mã giảm giá tiktok cách bán hàng trên tiktok tiktok shop logo cách mở tiktok shop khi chưa đủ follow phí sàn tiktok bán hàng trên tiktok tiktok global shop tiktok shop affiliate tiktok.com vn tiếp thị liên kết tiktok liên kết tiktok shop tiktokshop cách đăng ký tiktok shop trên điện thoại tiktok desktop những từ bị cấm trên tiktok chạy quảng cáo tiktok shop cách xóa tài khoản tiktok seller đổi tên tiktok shop cách mua hàng trên tiktok tra mã vận đơn tiktok shop mã khuyến mãi tiktok shop tên cửa hàng tiktok shop hay phí vận chuyển tiktok shop ai trả cách thêm sản phẩm liên kết trên tiktok shop cách mở tiktok shop trên điện thoại cách mở tiktok shop điều kiện mở tiktok shop khóa học tiktok shop tổng đài tiktok đơn vị vận chuyển của tiktok shop cách rút tiền trên tiktok tiktok live cách xóa sản phẩm liên kết trên tiktok shop cách đăng bán hàng trên tiktok tiktokseller chính sách của tiktok shop đăng ký tài khoản nhận hoa hồng tiktok shop affiliate cách xoá sản phẩm trên tiktok shop cách rút tiền hoa hồng tiktok shop cách xem doanh thu trên tiktok shop ads tiktok shop ảnh tiktok shop tài khoản tiktok shop bị hủy kích hoạt đơn hàng tiktok mua hàng tiktok trên máy tính mã cửa hàng tiktok shop voucher tiktok shop cách gắn giỏ hàng trên tiktok hoa hồng tiktok shop cách xác nhận đơn hàng trên tiktok shop đơn vị vận chuyển tiktok shop cách lấy link tiktok shop phí sàn tiktok shop tiktok shop giao hàng bao lâu tiktok cách kiếm tiền trên tiktok tiktok.com seller tiktok mã giảm giá tiktok hôm nay giao diện tiktok tiktok shop không hiện sản phẩm khiếu nại tiktok shop thêm sản phẩm vào tiktok shop thanh toán tiktok bằng momo cách trả hàng trên tiktok tiktok có cho kiểm hàng không cách xoá tiktok shop trả hàng hoàn tiền tiktok doanh thu tiktok shop tiktok shop icon cách hủy đơn hàng trên tiktok tiktok shop pc thuế tiktok shop cách liên kết tiktok shop cách xoá đánh giá trên tiktok mã giảm giá tiktok cho đơn hàng đầu tiên cách live bán hàng trên tiktok tax code tiktok là gì cách mở thanh toán khi nhận hàng trên tiktok cách làm affiliate tiktok mua kênh tiktok mã freeship tiktok thay đổi quốc gia trên tiktok shop hoa hồng affiliate tiktok tải tiktok seller về máy tính buff đơn tiktok mua acc tiktok máy in đơn tiktok tiktok shop ra đời khi nào cách xem thông tin khách hàng trên tiktok shop kháng nghị tiktok shop tiktok shop tuyển dụng cách kiếm tiền hoa hồng trên tiktok cách tạo giỏ hàng trên tiktok tiktok shop api chính sách bán hàng trên tiktok cách mua hàng trên tiktok được giảm giá khóa học tiktok tiktok seller center tiktok academy đăng sản phẩm lên tiktok shop bị đình chỉ nghiên cứu khoa học về tiktok shop không vào được tiktok shop cách livestream bán hàng trên tiktok trả hàng trên tiktok có mất phí không dịch vụ tiktok shop cách tạo tiktok shop trên máy tính quảng cáo tiktok shop cách gắn link sản phẩm trên tiktok cách đăng ký bán hàng trên tiktok tra cứu đơn hàng tiktok cách kiểm tra đơn hàng trên tiktok cách xây dựng kênh tiktok bán hàng cách sửa đánh giá trên tiktok shop cách đăng sản phẩm lên tiktok shop cách chạy quảng cáo tiktok cách xoá sản phẩm affiliate trên tiktok shop cách đăng thực phẩm chức năng lên tiktok shop tài khoản chính thức và tài khoản tiếp thị api tiktok chạy quảng cáo tiktok shop trên máy tính tài nguyên shop tiktok shop đăng nhập livestream tiktok giá trị biến thể là gì trên tiktok bán đồ ăn trên tiktok shop cách hủy đơn hàng trên tiktok đang chờ vận chuyển sách tiktok tài liệu tiktok shop cách vào tiktok shop bạn đã đạt đến giới hạn số lượng tài khoản có thể đăng ký tiktok shop seller center tiktok shop seller đăng nhập tiktok shop tạo tiktok shop cách đăng ký tiktok shop cách bán hàng trên tiktok shop mở tiktok shop 1 cccd đăng ký được bao nhiêu tiktok shop bán hàng trên tiktok shop tiktok shop là gì 1 cmnd đăng ký được mấy tài khoản tiktok shop logo tiktok shop tổng đài hỗ trợ tiktok shop tiếp thị liên kết tiktok shop tổng đài tiktok shop tải tiktok shop tiktok shop streamer desktop các từ bị cấm trên tiktok shop cách lập tiktok shop affiliate tiktok shop 1 cccd tạo được bao nhiêu tiktok shop cách tạo shop trên tiktok tạo tài khoản tiktok shop một cccd đăng ký được mấy tài khoản tiktok shop xoá tiktok shop cách đổi tên tiktok shop mua hàng trên tiktok shop cách mua hàng trên tiktok shop tạo shop trên tiktok mã tiktok shop tiktok shop mua hàng tiktok shop seller center vietnam hủy liên kết tiktok shop cách làm tiktok shop tiktok shop la gì mã giảm giá tiktok shop bán hàng tiktok shop phí sàn tiktok shop 2024 shopee express mã giảm giá shopee shopee food voucher shopee shopee affiliate shopeê tổng đài shopee shopee mall shopee kênh người bán shopee tuyển dụng affiliate shopee shopee seller tải shopee tra mã vận đơn shopee express shopee nghĩa ô gắn tag shopee live cách bán hàng trên shopee logo shopee bưu cục shopee express shopee express tracking mã freeship shopee proxy shopee shopee analytics tra mã vận đơn shopee tra mã đơn hàng shopee express mua nick shopee shopee mall là gì shopee express tuyển dụng shopee singapore kho sw soc shopee ở đâu shopee bán hàng gắn tag live shopee shopee express tra cứu cách săn sale shopee tra cứu shopee express tra cứu đơn hàng shopee shopee express mã vận đơn bưu cục shopee express gần đây shopee bán tra cứu đơn hàng shopee express tra cứu vận đơn shopee express shopee thailand nhanh shopee express shopee logo gắn link shopee live kênh người bán shopee voucher shopee hôm nay cách hủy đơn hàng trên shopee bán hàng trên shopee shopee voucher shopee express bưu cục hotline shopee shopee career shopee pay shopee seller center mã vận đơn shopee tra mã vận đơn standard express shopee mã giảm giá shopee hôm nay săn sale shopee shopee apk bán hàng trên shopee mất phí bao nhiêu mã giảm giá shopee cho mọi đơn hàng shopee xpress tổng đài shopee express phí sàn shopee lỗi m02 shopee spaylater shopee là gì mã shopee shopee live cách liên kết tài khoản ngân hàng với shopee pay mã voucher shopee kho bw soc shopee ở đâu shopee malaysia gắn live shopee shopee của nước nào xem tổng tiền đã mua trên shopee trên điện thoại tag live shopee kho shopee express cách trả hàng shopee kiểm tra đơn hàng shopee cách đặt hàng trên shopee seller shopee tag shopee live mã giới thiệu shopee cách xóa tài khoản shopee danh sách bưu cục shopee express mã voucher shopee hôm nay bán hàng shopee cách săn voucher shopee spaylater shopee có an toàn không tổng đài shopee miễn phí standard express shopee tra cứu vận đơn số dư tài khoản shopee tiếp thị liên kết shopee shopee bị lỗi cách mua hàng trên shopee taobao shopee cách đăng ký bán hàng trên shopee tra cứu mã vận đơn shopee spaylater shopee tải shopee pc sinh nhật shopee chăm sóc khách hàng shopee voucher shopee 0đ cảng pingxiang shopee ở đâu tuyển dụng shopee tải shopee trên máy tính m02 shopee magiamgia shopee shopee tracking cách hủy đơn hàng trên shopee khi đang giao shopee live pc đăng ký bán hàng trên shopee công ty shopee giao hàng shopee tài khoản shopee bị khóa shopee express gần đây săn mã freeship 0đ shopee hôm nay ảnh shopee lịch nghỉ tết shopee 2024 cskh shopee kho shopee nghĩa ô tra cứu mã vận đơn shopee express shopee wallet shopee thái lan shopee express tuyển dụng shipper shopee philippines cách tải shopee trên máy tính mã vận đơn shopee express tra cứu đơn shopee giảm giá shopee số dư tài khoản shopee là gì tải shopee về máy tính banner shopee số dư tài khoản shopee có mua hàng được không shopee merchant wallet shopee - tìm trên google shopee affiliate program seller own fleet tra cứu vận đơn shopee mã freeship shopee bannenbiet quảng cáo shopee tra mã shopee express hủy đơn shopee shopee food tuyển dụng mã shopee voucher thử thách shopee lỗi f02 shopee thời gian làm việc của shipper shopee express tra đơn shopee express tra cứu vận đơn shopee kol shopee link gắn tag shopee live chạy quảng cáo shopee đánh giá shopee tra số shipper shopee express live shopee xóa tài khoản shopee shopee merchant mã freeship shopee hôm nay mã đơn hàng shopee shopee ex mẫu đánh giá shopee lướt shopee nhận quà liên quân voucher freeship shopee khiếu nại shopee tuyển dụng shopee express cách làm tiếp thị liên kết shopee shopee nghĩa ô là ở đâu phí shopee hotline shopee express kho thâm quyến shopee ở đâu công ty tnhh shopee express cách làm affiliate shopee trả hàng hoàn tiền shopee tool gắn tag shopee live bưu cục shopee express hà nội tra đơn hàng shopee cách trả hàng trên shopee tài khoản shopee bị khóa f02 điểm gửi hàng shopee express tra cứu đơn shopee express mã giới thiệu kol shopee cách săn mã giảm giá shopee cách trả hàng trên shopee khi đã nhận hàng tang follow shopee vinalike cách tra số điện thoại shipper shopee express mã shopee hôm nay cách hủy đơn trên shopee ví trả sau shopee logo shopee png cách đăng ký bán hàng trên shopee bằng điện thoại tra vận đơn shopee express lịch nghỉ tết của shopee express 2024 văn mẫu đánh giá shopee huỷ đơn hàng shopee shopee express vận đơn seller own fleet - vận chuyển quốc tế shopee săn voucher shopee shopee sale shopee express hotline hotline shopee food tổng đài shopee food ví shopee pay là gì cách lấy mã giảm giá shopee phí thanh toán shopee gắn link live shopee cách liên kết tài khoản ngân hàng với shopee cách xem tổng số tiền đã mua trên shopee ví shopee shopee liên quân đăng ký shopee mall icon shopee cách làm kol shopee đăng ký kol shopee shopee analytic shopee icon đăng ký shopee food shopee shopee.vn app shopee indonesia shopee taiwan shopeepay spaylater là gì download video shopee spx tracking shopee food logo dropshipping shopee subaccount shopee partner flash sale shopee api email shopee shopee video cách khắc phục lỗi m02 shopee bw soc ở đâu shopee 11.11 liên kết thẻ tín dụng với shopeepay shopee tuyển dụng thực tập sinh link shopee merchant wallet lịch sale shopee black friday shopee ronaldo shopee cảng pingxiang game shopee shopee 6.6 shopee làm việc đến ngày nào thì nghỉ tết voucher shopee food seller own fleet standard express.com shopeefood tuyển dụng shopee xu

Habib Souaïdia and Algerian state crime

ISCI is a cross-disciplinary research centre working to further our understanding of state crime: organisational deviance violating human rights

Habib Souaïdia and Algerian state crime

Habib Saouidia - Algerie Politique

In April 2015, Habib Souaïdia made a rare sortie into the public domain, publishing a serious indictment of the role of Algeria’s secret intelligence service, the Département du Renseignement et de la Sécurité (DRS), in recent terrorist activities in Algeria and the attempted destabilisation of neighbouring states.

Habib Souaïdia, is a 46 year-old Algerian (born, in Tebessa, Algeria, in 1969) described by Wikipedia as “an Algerian writer and former member of the Algerian army’s Special Forces.” That is not incorrect, but it is misses the substance.

Souaïdia enlisted in the Algerian army in 1989 and became a junior officer (second lieutenant) and parachutist in the elite Special Forces. In the 1990s, he witnessed the atrocities being committed by the Algerian army and DRS against both known and suspected Islamists and, more significantly, innocent Algerian civilians, many of whom were massacred in cold blood by the DRS’s killing squads. The overall commander of the DRS at that time, General Mohamed “Toufik” Mediène, is still, to this day, the DRS boss. Until the restructuring of the DRS and his relative political demise in 2013, Mediène was without doubt the most powerful man in Algeria.

In 1995, Souaïdia was sentenced to four years imprisonment on trumped up charges. “They arrested me to silence me,” he later wrote, swearing that when he was released he would expose to the free world what his state had been doing.

He was released in 1999 and in 2000 obtained a passport and flew to France, where he tried to interest journalists in his story, which was a serious embarrassment to the French government. Both Presidents Francois Mitterrand and Jacques Chirac had backed the Algerian regime in its war against the Islamic fighters.

However, in November 2000 he was granted his request for political asylum. The following year (2001), he published his memoirs: La sale guerre. Le témoignage d’un ancient officier des forces spéciales de l’armée algérienne,1992-2000 (The Dirty War: The testimony of a former officer of the special forces of the Algerian army, 1992-2000″.[1]

When Souaïdia broke his silence in 2001, he wrote: “When I enlisted in the army in 1989, I never imagined that I would be a direct witness of the tragedy that has befallen my country …

“I have seen my colleagues set fire to a boy of 15, who burned like a living torch. I have seen soldiers slaughtering civilians and blaming ‘the terrorists.’ I have seen senior officers murdering in cold blood simple people who were suspected of Islamic activities. I have seen officers torturing Islamic activists to death. I have seen too many things. I cannot remain silent. These are sufficient reasons for breaking my silence.”[2]

ap97082903974La Sale Guerre is in many respects the most important work to come out of Algeria’s Dirty War. The reason for that is because the Algerian regime, in the personage of General Khaled Nezzar, the Defence Minister at the time of the atrocities, sued Souaïdia for libel. In a long, high profile case in a Paris court, Nezzar lost his case, thus rubber-stamping Souaïdia’s testimony as the correct and truthful account of the massacres. As the years have gone by, multiple works, notably An Enquiry into the Algerian Massacres (1999)[3], have affirmed the status of Habib Souaïdia’s testimony and the criminal roles of the Algerian regime, its army and DRS.

The conclusion of La Sale Guerre is that the “main problem [in Algeria] is injustice”. Souaïdia wrote: “If an end is put to the injustice, peace will come to Algeria. Therefore it is necessary to stop the corrupt individuals who are continuing to rob the huge assets of the Algerian people.”

That was in 2001. Today, the crimes of the Algerian regime are perhaps even greater, not so much in terms of killing their own innocent citizens, but in terms of “injustice”, the abuse of human rights and the endemic, oligarchic corruption of a regime that is continuing, perhaps on an even greater scale, to rob the Algerian people of their “huge assets”.

It is against the background of Algeria’s current political and oil-price-driven economic crises that Souaïdia has published his latest indictment of the Algerian regime and its secret intelligence service, the DRS.

The article, entitled “De l’assassinat d’Hervé Gourdel à la destabilisation tunisienne: manipulations et intox des services secrets algériens”, was published by Algeria-Watch on 27 April 2015.

If only half of Souaïdia’s article is true, then it has serious implications for security throughout most of North Africa.

The obvious question, however, is how much of Souaïdia’s article is true? I can give two assurances. The first is that almost everything that Souaïdia has said and written since 2001, barring a few largely irrelevant details, has been proven to be correct. Souaïdia thus has credibility. The second assurance I can give is that both my own research, as well as a number of corroborative sources, tends to verify all six of Souaïdia’s main claims.

The only noticeable error relates to the death of hostages and terrorists at the Tiguentourine gas facility (In Amenas) in January 2013, when he says that thirty-eight Western hostages, an Algerian and twenty-nine terrorists, were all killed by fire from DRS helicopters. As we now know from the details of the In Amenas inquest held in London recently, not all the hostages were killed in the helicopter assault to which Souaïdia is referring. Although several of the hostages were killed by fire from the Algerian army, the fire seems to have come more from troops on the ground rather than the helicopters.

The reason for this error is that Souaïdia obtained details of what happened at Tiguentourine from his own sources and either directly or indirectly from Algerian soldiers who were there. Many of them saw rockets being fired from the helicopters and assumed that the rockets caused the explosion of the vehicles carrying both terrorists and their hostages. In fact, the inquest evidence indicates that the explosions came from bombs (explosives) being carried by the terrorists in the vehicles, which were probably detonated either by the terrorists or by army ground fire that was being directed into the vehicles and not by rockets fired from the helicopters.

Souaïdia’s article covers six broad issues:

(1) That the DRS was behind the abduction and murder of French tourist Hervé Gourdel in September 2014.

(2)How the DRS prolonged their manipulation of Islamist violence after the end of the civil war of the 1990s.

(3) The relationship between hostage taking and the creation of new armed groups.

(4) Tension between the army and DRS.

(5) The involvement of the DRS in the destabilisation of Tunisia.[4]

(6) Concluding thoughts on the re-emergence of the DRS.

 Families members of disappeared from Algeria's civil war - ICTJ

The murder of Hervé Gourdel

Souaïdia alleges that the abduction and beheading of Hervé Gourdel in September 2014 was not the work of the Islamic State (IS), or Daesh, as it is known locally in Arabic, as officially claimed, but the work of Algeria’s DRS, and in the same pattern as its manipulation of Islamist armed (“terrorist”) groups over the previous 20 or more years.

Frenchman Hervé Gourdel (55) was kidnapped by an extremist group in Algeria’s Kabylie region on 21 September and beheaded three days later on 24 September.

Gourdel, an alpine guide from Nice, was starting a trekking holiday in the mountainous Djurdjura National Park in Tizi Ouzou wilaya. He arrived in Algeria on 20 September and spent that night at a ski lodge near the town of Tikjda in the Djurdjura. The next day, he was driving through the heart of the Djurdjura Mountains with two Algerian companions near the village of Ait Ouabane when he was stopped by a group of armed men. The gunmen released the Algerians, who alerted the authorities, and took Gourdel.

The next day, an online video showed Gourdel flanked by masked, armed men. In an address directed to France’s President François Hollande, a member of the group threatened to kill Gourdel unless France’s airstrikes against IS militants in Iraq were halted within 24 hours.

The group said it was answering a call by IS spokesman Abu Muhammad al-Adnani, who, in a 42-minute audio statement released on 21 September, urged followers to kill Americans and Europeans, “especially the spiteful and filthy French”.

The kidnappers said they were members of the Algerian group Jund al-Khilafah (en Algérie), also known as Soldiers of the Caliphate. The group, believed to be an Al Qaida splinter group, is said to have pledged allegiance to the IS. It had announced itself in Algeria on 13 September, with its leader named as Abdelmalek El Gouri, also known as Khaled Abu Suleimane (sometimes spelt Selman).

Algerian news services, drawing on information provided by the security services, (i.e. the DRS), described Jund al-Khilafah as a “bloodthirsty” splinter group numbering less than 50, made up of remnants of Al Qaida in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM), that operated in the maquis of Boumerdès, Tizi Ouzou and Bouïra. AQIM, like its predecessors, the Groupes Islamiques Armées (GIA) and Groupe Salafiste pour le Prédication et le Combat (GSPC), was known to have been well infiltrated by the DRS. El Gouri was reported by Algerian security sources as having been behind all the suicide attacks undertaken in the region between 2007 and 2011, since when the group is said to have been dwindling in number as a result of military action and low recruitment. El Gouri’s creation of Jund al-Khilafah was reported in the Algeria media as being an attempt to get back on to the national stage and win support from Salafist extremists.

From the outset, there were suspicions. Although entry into the Djurdjura is not officially forbidden, the Algerian authorities would normally strongly advise a foreigner not to enter the region because of the known risk of terrorism and kidnapping in the area. Gourdel’s visa application, in which he appears to have said he was going to trek in the Djurdjura, would have been forwarded to the Algerian authorities. He would almost certainly have been advised not to enter the region. If he persisted, then entry would probably have been made difficult for him, or possibly even forbidden by the local military. It would not be unheard of for a military escort to be provided. None of this appears to have happened.

Equally suspicious were that the kidnappers’ demands were out of keeping with all previous AQIM kidnap demands. Although this was ostensibly a new group, focusing on one immediate situation – French military attacks on IS in Iraq, my sources pointed out that these militants originated from GSPC/AQIM whose kidnap demands were nearly always multiple and always spread over a long period of time, usually many months.

A 24-hour warning was too short for France to make a decision regarding a change of policy in Iraq, especially at a time when the key political leaders were attending a UN meeting in New York. It was almost as if the group was deliberately not giving France enough time in which to respond.

Souaïdia’s evidence for DRS involvement in the Gourdel case, derived from his own contacts and sources, is much the same as that provided to me by the Rachad Movement. It lies in both the speed of transmission of the kidnappers’ videos and their content.

For instance, both Souaïdia and my Rachad sources, put forward a lot of technological evidence to explain that the kidnappers could not have broadcast their videos on the Web so quickly from their isolated location in the Djurdjura mountains, especially whenbroadband is so difficult to access in such remote parts of Algeria, without the help of an external agency, such as the DRS.

Souaïdia also raises the question of why the jihadists who killed Gourdel, as in other recent AQIM videos, covered their faces, unlike the jihadists of the 1990s. He suggests it is to hide their white arms and overweight bodies that indicate that they are not true jihadists (used to fighting in the open country) and that they now cover their faces to avoid recognition.

Souaïdia also raises a lot of technical issues about the locations where the videos were made, suggesting that they were stage-managed. For example, he points out that the third video shows the armed group being filmed with an array of heavy weapons, none of which appeared in the list of weaponry recovered later by the army.

These and other anomalies have been noted by several other analysts, notably those of the Rachad movement, suggesting that the videoed locations were not only contrived, but also possibly prepared before Gourdel’s abduction.

Another suspicion raised by several other sources is why it took the Algerians almost four months to find the decapitated remains of Gourdel’s body when they claim to have had some 2,000-3,000 troops combing the area.

Souaïdia suggests that the killing was a propaganda exercise to convince Algerians and the outside world that IS (Daesh) had established itself in Algeria. The problem now, eight months later, is that there is still no firm evidence of this.

While this view is widely believed by many Algerians, there is also another angle to it. This is that some Algerian sources believe that Gourdel’s kidnap and murder were designed to put pressure on the Algerian regime and its army to intervene in Libya. At the time, France was placing heavy pressure on Algeria to intervene military in Libya. Although the Algerian regime was divided on the question, the majority of the government and army were opposed to such action. If Gourdel’s murder was a “false-flag” operation, as Souaïdia and other sources suggest, it may have been undertaken by rogue elements within Algeria’s security apparatus, and perhaps also in France, to provide the regime with a pretext and legitimacy for “going into Libya” on the grounds that “ISIS is there”.

How the DRS prolonged their manipulation of Islamist violence

Souaïdia gives a long explanation of how the DRS managed to prolong its manipulation of Islamic violence long after the end of the civil war of the 1990s by using President Bouteflika’s “national reconciliation policy” to reinsert many of the released prisoners, still under DRS control, back into the terrorist circuit. Souaïdia claims that Abdelmalek El Gouri (a. k. a. Khaled Abu Suleimane), the supposed emir of Khakli (‘Soldiers of the Caliphate’), the IS group alleged to have killed Gourdel, and his deputy Othmane El-Assimi, belonged to this category of “released prisoners” that were subsequently “re-used” by the DRS

The DRS’s selection of prisoners was made carefully. According to Souaïdia, those known to have committed themselves to a change of life and peace were retained in prison. Those who had a radical profile or were willing to work with the DRS were released. One of the most famous of these was the infamous Abdelfatah Hamadache, known by DRS officers as the “honey pot”, because his radical speeches attracted young people “like bees to honey”. He was soon released, encouraged to found a radical movement and portrayed by the Algerian media as an Islamist leader when he was in fact a DRS agent.

Hostage-taking and the creation of new armed groups

There is much that could be said about hostage-taking and the DRS, not least that the official accounts of each incident raise more questions than answers. However, the point that Souaïdia makes is that before each hostage-taking, “security” journalists working for the Algerian press published disinformation provided by the DRS that announced the creation of a new armed group that stemmed from dissent within a previous group, without the corroboration of any other independent source of information.

Souaïdia cites the split of the GIA in 1997 to form the GSPC, which became AQIM in 2006, with further splits to form MUJAO in 2011 and Mokhtar ben Mokhtar’s “Signatories of Blood” in 2012. The most recent was the supposed split from AQIM in August 2014 to create Jund al-Khilafah. Souaïdia could also have mentioned Ansar al-Din, also in 2011, that was led by Iyad ag Ghali, known by many as the “DRS’s man in Mali”. Souaïdia might also have mentioned what is believed to be the genesis of a new split from Mokhtar ben Mokhtar’s “Signatories of Blood” or “Mourabitoune” as they are also known.

Souaïdia is technically incorrect if he is meaning that a new armed group is created before every single kidnap. But he is broadly correct if he means every new spate or phase of kidnapping.

In addition to Souaïdia’s comments, my own research has revealed that the leader of every armed group that has been involved in the taking of some 110 western hostages since 2002 (including In Amenas in 2013) has been associated with the DRS in the way that Souaïdia describes. Indeed, in some cases, what we might call “valuable” hostages, such as four of those kidnapped from Areva’s Arlit uranium mine in September 2010 and released on 29 October 2013, have been held captive in Algeria. This was almost certainly for their safety. However, RFI (Radio France International) unwittingly let the cat of the bag when it reported that local Malian Tuareg, with whom their reporters had been talking on the day of the hostages’ release, confirmed that the hostages had been held “just on the other side of the frontier in Algerian territory, to the north of Bourassa (Boughassa).” That area is an Algerian military zone.

 

Tension between the army and DRS

Between September 2013 and January 2014, the long battle within the Algerian regime, the so-called battle of the clans, between the presidency of Abdelaziz Bouteflika and General Mediène’s DRS seemed to come to a sudden and unexpected end with the Presidency, through the office of General Gaïd Salah, the Deputy Minister of defence and Chief of the General Staff, dismissing most of the DRS’s top Generals. By September 2013, Bouteflika, although severely weakened physically by a stroke in April 2013, had closely allied himself with army chief General Gaïd Salah, so much so that the restructuring of the DRS appeared to be a direct conflict between the army, under the command of Gaïd Salah, and the DRS.

Although DRS boss, General Mediène, has remained in post, albeit severely weakened, most of his top commanders, notably General M’henna Djebbar, Head of the Direction Centrale de la Sécurité de l’Armée (DCSA); General Athmane “Bashir” Tartag, Head of the Direction de la Sécurité Intérieure (DSI) and the Direction du Contre-espionnage (DCE); General Rachid “Attafi” Lallali, Head of the Documentation et de la Sécurité Extérieure (DDSE); and General Hassan (Hacène), whose proper name is Abdelkhader ait Ourabi, head of the DRS’s Special Intervention Forces, were “retired” or dismissed from office under one pretext or another. Many of DRS’s key departments were either closed down or transferred to the control of the army.

Most analysts believe that the pretext for this dramatic move by the presidency and army against the DRS was the DRS’s failures at In Amenas. Most analysts and commentators believe that the DRS was paying for price for its lapse in security. My own view, published in other ISCI articles, is because In Amenas was a DRS false-flag operation that went disastrously wrong. It this turned out to be extremely costly for Algeria, both economically in terms of lost revenues, and geopolitically.

While Souaïdia’s analysis of In Amenas is broadly similar to my own, he does add a dramatically new and immensely important dimension to our understanding of the nature and outcome of the battle between the Presidency and the DRS and what appears to be the continued role of the DRS in Algerian state terrorism subsequent to the In Amenas attack..

The role of the General Hassan and the DRS in the destabilisation of Tunisia

Souaïdia’s wholly new contribution to our understanding of contemporary Algeria stems from information given to him by his informants regarding General Hassan’s links with “emirs” acting under his orders in Tunisia.

Since the start of the “Arab Spring” in Tunisia in late-2010 and early-2011, there have been a stream of allegations about the involvement of Algeria’s DRS in trying to prevent the emergence of democratic governance in Tunisia and what Souaïdia calls the “democratic contagion of Algeria”, and of then trying to destabilise Tunisia’s fledging new government. But there has been no hard evidence: no smoking gun.

The latest such incident was the bloody attack on the Bardo museum in Tunis on 18 March. As with many other terrorist incidents in Tunisia, it was not long before it emerged that the leader of the attack was of Algerian origin. On 22 March, Tunisia’s new President, Beji Caid Essebsi, said, visibly upset, in an interview with the French TV channel I-Tele: “Whenever a terrorist group is flushed out in Tunisia, it has an Algerian leader.”

Tayeb Belaïz, Algeria’s Interior Minister at that time, responded immediately saying: “Terrorism has no nationality, no country, no religion, no colour and no humanism. It can manifest itself in any territory and I make no difference between terrorists whatever their name.”

However, Souaïdia suggests that one of those “names” is that of the DRS. In fact, Souaïdia says that he has been informed by many of his former colleagues that the leaders of some of the jihadist groups sowing terror in Tunisia “take their orders from Algiers.”

Souaïdia went on to say that following the military suppression of terrorist activity in Tunisia’s Mount Chaambi border area in 2013, the Tunisian army recovered the mobile phones and SIM cards from the bodies of several Algerian jihadists killed in the region. An analysis of the SIM cards by the Tunisian army revealed their communications with DRS officials in Algiers, including their phone numbers and even their nicknames.

If this information is correct, it is strong evidence of what has long been suspected, namely that Algeria’s DRS is bent on destabilising its neighbour, Tunisia, in the same way that it did Mali.

Most of the “terrorists” in the Mt Chaambi area are believed to have moved into the region after the French military flushed them out of Mali earlier in the year. There, they had mostly been part of AQIM, whose objective in Mali was to weaken the Tuareg rebels who had taken control of most of northern Mali (“Azawad”) and also destabilise Mali as part of an Algerian-backed Islamist insurgency. AQIM’s leader in the area, now dead, was Abdelhamid abou Zaïd, another DRS operative. AQIMs forces in Mali were supplied and supported by Algeria’s DRS, with food, fuel and, as we learnt in early 2014, arms belonging to Algeria’s army.

Souaïdia’s evidence from Tunisia throws a great of light on the bizarre situation in which General Hassan found himself in January-February 2014.

Souaïdia does not give us the date when the Tunisian army found the SIM card links between the Mt Chaambi fighters and the DRS, nor the date that the Tunisian authorities handed the evidence over to the US intelligence services, who, in turn are said by Souaïdia to have asked Algeria’s army chiefs to put a stop to this practice once and for all. The date would have been at some time in the latter part of 2013 and most likely close to the end of the year.

Hence Algeria’s creation in December 2013 of a “special security commission” under the control of General Gaïd Salah and the presidency in an attempt to get on top of those DRS officers who were in control of the information and intelligence on both corruption and security issues and who maintained suspect ties with the jihadists.

On 13 January 2014, official notification of Hassan’s “retirement” was posted. At that time, I did not know about General Hassan’s involvement in Tunisia.

Behind the scenes, a massive power struggle was brewing up. At some point in January, General Hassan was summonsed to answer extremely serious questions, or charges, before the military prosecutor. The charges against Hassan were: creating armed groups; retaining and withholding disclosure of weapons of war and making false statements of weaponry stocks used or placed at his disposition in the course of his exclusive prerogatives in the fight against terrorism. As Souaïdia said, such charges effectively amounted to treason.

What Souaïdia may not have known is that there was a technical basis for these charges. These were that Hassan was responsible for recovering the weaponry that the Algerian army had covertly supplied to the Islamist insurgencies in Mali and return it to its original army depots. However, as this was a secret operation and one that had to be kept completely under wraps, Hassan had to move the weaponry across Algeria without notifying the administration of each wilaya (province) being traversed, as is required by law.

When Hassan refused to respond to the summons, General Lakhdar, who had replaced General M’henna Djebbar in September, was sent to try and get him to co-operate, but he again refused. Then, on Wednesday 5 February, Gaïd Salah ordered the mobilisation of three sections of the Gendarmerie to arrest him. When Hassan refused to comply, the gendarmes broke down the door of his house and took him by force. On Friday 7 February, Hassan was ordered to appear before an investigative military judge in Blida.

On February 12, General Mediène’s DRS, or at least what remained of it, launched a devastating attack on General Gaïd Salah. The attack was in the form of an interview by retired General Hocine Benhadid in both the El Watan and El Khabar daily newspapers. The El Watan headline read: “Bouteflika must step down with dignity and Gaïd Salah is not credible.”

Benhadid – a former commander of the mythical 8th Armoured Division, adviser to former president Liamine Zeroual (1994-99), and one of the few Generals to resign (at the age of only 52 in 1996) – broke his ten-year silence to denounce what he called a “dangerous situation”.

In a brutal attack on Gaïd Salah, Benhadid said: “The Chief of Staff has no credibility, and no one is fond of him.”

Benhadid also called on Bouteflika to step down “with dignity” and not run for a fourth term in April (2014). He said someone who was “sick” and the “hostage of his entourage” could not guarantee the country’s stability.

The former General, who said he was speaking on behalf of others in the armed forces, but without saying whom, “because we cannot let this situation continue”, also accused the president’s inner circle of “treason” after Amar Saâdani, Secretary-General of the ruling FLN party, accused General Mediène of “interfering in politics to the detriment of the country’s security”.

In addition to his attack on Gaïd Salah, Benhadid also singled out Bouteflika’s brother Saïd Bouteflika for criticism, whom he described as the “main actor” in the presidential clan. In a direct reference to the involvement of the Bouteflika clan in the corruption that shrouds the regime, he accused Bouteflika’s entourage of “playing with Algeria’s destiny” in order to “save its skin, because corruption has reached dangerous levels”.

This was a demonstration of Generals coming to the defence of Mediène. Would we see Generals coming to the defence of Gaïd Salah? The answer is probably no. Benhadid’s statements immediately raised questions as to whether Generals might no longer accept Gaïd Salah as their supreme commander by perhaps resigning. His intervention even opened up questions as to whether it was the precursor of a possible, although unlikely, military coup d’état.

However, on that high point, with both parties seemingly going for the jugular, the fighting stopped. There were no more allegations and counter allegations, no more public attacks and damning disclosures by either side and nothing more has been heard of General Hassan’s trial. There was silence in the press and the charges against Hassan simply “disappeared”.

The re-emergence of the DRS

What happened?

Those were the events, and my analysis of them, as I knew them at the time. However, we now know, thanks to Souaïdia, that the President’s entourage, notably General Gaïd Salah, was in possession, presumably thanks to the Americans, of the DRS’s activities in Tunisia and General Hassan’s operational command of them.

Souaïdia believes that the restructuring of the DRS in 2013-2014 was also a consequence of the discovery of General Hassan’s links with “emirs” in Tunisia acting under his orders, as much as it was a consequence of the other reasons that I have put forward, notably In Amenas.

Souaïdia believes that Mediène, who was neither dismissed nor retired at that time, resisted this pressure on him from the presidency and Gaïd Salah and in February 2014 reached a compromise with them.

Indeed, one outcome of this compromise, according to Souaïdia, was that media attacks against the DRS stopped abruptly and no further action was taken against General Hassan. This explains what Souaïdia calls the “temporary” arrest of General Hassan.

The one clue that a deal had been done between the presidency, Gaïd Salah and Mediène was an article by Salima Tlemçani in El Watan on 13 February, the day after Benhadid’s attack.

Salima Tlemçani, whose real name is Zineb Oubouchou, although a professional and extremely able journalist, has had a close “working relationship” with the DRS since the 1990s, with the result that her articles often contain valuable insights into DRS thinking or “messaging”. In this particular article, although very difficult to interpret, there are indications that some sort of deal is in the offing.

Another outcome, as Souaïdia tells us, is that seven months later, in this poisonous atmosphere between Mediène and the army, Mediène’s officers “staked out their territory against the army chief of staff by kidnapping and murdering Hervé Gourdel. In so doing, they reminded the French authorities that in the ever-present struggle against terrorism, now represented by the Islamic State, the DRS is as indispensable to them as the Algerian army.”

If Souaïdia’s analysis is correct, and there is much corroborative evidence to suggest that it is, then Algeria and neighbouring countries, especially Tunisia, Mali and Niger, but also perhaps Mauritania and Morocco (and of course Libya) can expect more manipulation of “Islamic terrorism” in the same manner that Algerian state terrorism has held sway across the region for the past generation.

Endnotes

[1]Habib Souaïdia, La sale guerre. Le témoignage d’un ancient officier des forces spéciales de l’armée algérienne,1992-2000 (The Dirty War: The testimony of a former officer of the special forces of the Algerian army, 1992-2000″. Preface by Ferdinando Imposimato, La Decouverte, 2001, 203 pages.).

[2]Daniel Ben Simon, Ha’aretz (Israel) “I cannot remain silent”, Algeria-Watch, April 20, 2001. http://www.algeria-watch.org/farticle/sale_guerre/haaretz.htm

[3]An Enquiry into the Algerian Massacres. Hoggar Press, 1999, 1,473 pages, with Forewords by Professor Noam Chomsky and Lord Eric Avebury.

[4] This article was written a few days before the “terrorist” attack on Tunisia’s tourist resort of Sousse in which at least 27 tourists (possibly more) were killed. No changes have been made to the article in the light of that attack.